Plaintiff

Technology Properties Limited LLC

10 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
10
Active
0
10 closed
Filed
2012–2015
Top venue
N.D. California
7 cases

Company profile

Technology Properties Limited LLC ("TPL," also styled The TPL Group) is a privately held intellectual-property company headquartered at 20883 Stevens Creek Boulevard, Suite 100, Cupertino, California. Sources date its founding to 1988–1989. It has no public ticker; no employee count or revenue figures are disclosed in public sources. Its principals have included chairman Daniel E. Leckrone and inventor Charles H. Moore, TPL's chief technology officer.

TPL is not an operating company. It develops, manages and commercializes patent portfolios — a non-practicing entity / patent-assertion entity. Its licensing agent was Alliacense Limited LLC (Cupertino), described as "a TPL Group Enterprise." TPL's principal asset is the Moore Microprocessor Patent (MMP) Portfolio — seven U.S. patents plus European and Japanese counterparts covering microprocessor clocking (separate CPU/I/O clocks), multi-core/embedded-memory designs and multi-instruction fetching — jointly owned with the publicly traded Patriot Scientific Corporation through the joint venture Phoenix Digital Solutions LLC. MMP was named for co-inventor Charles Moore (creator of the Forth language). TPL also asserted CORE Flash Portfolio patents. Its portfolio was licensed to Intel, AMD, HP, Fujitsu, Sony, Nokia and others; enforcement support later moved to Dominion Harbor Group.

Litigation posture: All 10 tracked cases are as plaintiff and none as defendant — the profile of a pure patent enforcer/licensor. Venues are the U.S. International Trade Commission, the Northern District of California, and the Federal Circuit. Earlier enforcement (2005–2008) was filed in the plaintiff-friendly Eastern District of Texas, alongside parallel ITC actions.

Notable cases: A July 2012 wave of suits and an ITC complaint targeted Acer, Huawei, ZTE, Samsung, LG, Nintendo, Kyocera, Barnes & Noble and others over MMP patents. Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Huawei Technologies Co. reached the Federal Circuit (Nos. 16-1306 et al.), where the court in March 2017 partially vacated the district court's claim construction regarding the "entire oscillator" limitation of the '336 patent. MMP patents were originally filed in the 1980s and, per contemporaneous releases, were protected through 2015.

Keep this research.

Save to your free workspace, then choose whether to receive updates.

Filing activity

2012: 9 cases9'12'13'142015: 1 case'15
Cases filed per year with Technology Properties Limited LLC as plaintiff.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Huawei Technologies Co.

remanded
Docket:
16-1306
Filed:
2015-12-13
Patents:5809336

Consolidated appeal from the N.D. Cal. cases against Huawei, ZTE, Samsung, LG, and Nintendo. The Federal Circuit affirmed in part and vacated in part the district court's claim construction, upholding prosecution-history disclaimer requiring an oscillator whose frequency is not fixed by any external crystal, but rejecting the requirement that the oscillator not require a control signal; remanded. Companion docket numbers: 16-1307, 16-1309, 16-1310, 16-1311.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Acer Inc. et al.

no violation; investigation terminated
Docket:
337-TA-853
Filed:
2012-07-24
Terminated:
2014-02-19
Patents:5809336

ITC investigation asserting claims 1, 6, 7, 9–11 and 13–16 of the '336 patent. ALJ found no violation of Section 337; Commission affirmed no-infringement findings and terminated the investigation. Several respondents settled earlier.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.

remanded
Docket:
3:12-cv-03865
Filed:
2012-07-24
Patents:5809336

District-court counterpart to the ITC case asserting the '336 patent. Stipulated final judgment of non-infringement entered Nov. 13, 2015; appealed. Federal Circuit affirmed in part and vacated in part on claim construction and remanded. Further appeals filed in 2018; mandate in 18-1439 issued June 19, 2019.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. ZTE Corp.

remanded
Docket:
3:12-cv-03876
Filed:
2012-07-24
Patents:5809336

District-court counterpart to the ITC case asserting the '336 patent. Stipulated final judgment of non-infringement entered Nov. 13, 2015; appealed. Federal Circuit affirmed in part and vacated in part on claim construction and remanded. Further appeals filed in 2018; mandate in 18-1439 issued June 19, 2019.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.

remanded
Docket:
3:12-cv-03877
Filed:
2012-07-24
Patents:5809336

District-court counterpart to the ITC case asserting the '336 patent. Stipulated final judgment of non-infringement entered Nov. 13, 2015; appealed. Federal Circuit affirmed in part and vacated in part on claim construction and remanded. Further appeals filed in 2018; mandate in 18-1439 issued June 19, 2019.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. LG Electronics, Inc.

remanded
Docket:
3:12-cv-03880
Filed:
2012-07-24
Patents:5809336

District-court counterpart to the ITC case asserting the '336 patent. Stipulated final judgment of non-infringement entered Nov. 13, 2015; appealed. Federal Circuit affirmed in part and vacated in part on claim construction and remanded. Further appeals filed in 2018; mandate in 18-1439 issued June 19, 2019.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Nintendo Co., Ltd.

remanded
Docket:
3:12-cv-03881
Filed:
2012-07-24
Patents:5809336

District-court counterpart to the ITC case asserting the '336 patent. Stipulated final judgment of non-infringement entered Nov. 13, 2015; appealed. Federal Circuit affirmed in part and vacated in part on claim construction and remanded. Further appeals filed in 2018; mandate in 18-1439 issued June 19, 2019.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Kyocera Corp.

stayed
Docket:
4:12-cv-03860 (YGR)
Filed:
2012-07-24

Part of the July 24, 2012 coordinated N.D. Cal. campaign asserting '336, '749 and '890 against Kyocera. On Nov. 26, 2012, the entire action was stayed pending the ITC investigation.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Barnes & Noble, Inc. et al.

stayed; DJ counterclaims; no trial date set
Filed:
2012-07-24

Part of the July 24, 2012 coordinated N.D. Cal. campaign asserting '336, '749 and '890 against Barnes & Noble over NOOK products. Stayed Sept. 26, 2012 – May 19, 2014 during the related ITC investigation; answered June 9, 2014 with DJ counterclaims. Later related to seven other TPL cases and referred to a magistrate judge; no trial date set.

Technology Properties Limited LLC et al. v. Acer et al.

no violation found
Filed:
2012-07-23

Section 337 ITC investigation filed July 23, 2012 alongside the N.D. Cal. campaign, asserting '336, '749 and '890. The ITC ultimately found no violation as to the asserted '336 patent claims; TPL did not appeal.