US 10334068

Here is a concise summary of US patent 10334068 based on the provided patent text and current legal status information:

US Patent 10334068: System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications

• Title: System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications
• Current Assignee: Razdog Holdings LLC
• Original Assignee: Individual
• Inventors: Chris Trahan, David Olszewski
• Filing Date: June 26, 2017 (for application US15/731,543)
• Issue Date: June 25, 2019
• Abstract: The patent discloses a cloud-based computer system and architecture for real-time management and migration through web-based content data and applications from multiple content sources or service providers. It features a log-in or master server as a single point of access, supporting an icon-based master web-page with a slide tool. This tool enables users on remote computing devices to scroll or page through content and applications from various sources in real-time.

Overview of Independent Claims:

US Patent 10334068 contains a single independent claim:

• Claim 1 (Plain-language overview): The invention describes a cloud-based computer system comprising:
  • A master server with a processor and memory, accessible by a user from remote computing devices over the internet/intranet.
  • A master application stored and executed on the master server. This application contains software coded to organize, pre-select, and stream content data and applications from multiple content sources or service providers simultaneously and in real-time to a master web-page. This master web-page is viewable on the remote computing devices. The master application also programs the processor on the remote computing devices to operate a slide tool program for scrolling or paging through this content and applications from the multiple sources simultaneously and in real-time via the master web-page.
  • A remote toolbox feature application that allows code to be written, selected, or deleted to enable and disable tool features. These features control how subsets of the content data or applications from the multiple sources are received, displayed, or organized. Furthermore, the master server collects analytics based on which tool features are enabled, using this data to target specific products, services, or information to the user.

Legal Status and Dockets:

As of the Google Patents fetch date (2026-07-28):

• The patent is Active and is estimated to expire on October 14, 2031.
• The patent family has ongoing litigation.
• A PTAB case (IPR2025-00308) was filed in 2025 and is currently pending and instituted.
• Two US cases were filed in the California Northern District Court in 2024, specifically case numbers 5:24-cv-03638 and 3:24-cv-03638.
• A request for reexamination was filed on April 22, 2025, and a reexamination certificate (C1) confirming the claims was issued on December 2, 2025.

A search for "10334068 USPTO" and "10334068 CAFC 2026 dockets" did not yield additional, more current, or contradictory information regarding the legal status or specific CAFC dockets for 2026 beyond what is already detailed in the provided Google Patents text. The provided patent text includes legal event dates up to December 2025 for reexamination and mentions PTAB and District Court cases, but no specific CAFC dockets for 2026 are listed directly in the provided information.The user asked to search USPTO and CAFC dockets for patent 10334068. The initial patent text provided detailed legal events, some of which are very recent (PTAB case instituted in 2025, reexamination confirmed claims in late 2025, and district court cases from 2024). The Google Patents page itself was fetched on 2026-07-28. My current date is 2026-04-26. This means the provided patent text contains legal status information that is more current than my analysis date.

I will use the legal status information provided in the patent text and confirm if any new CAFC dockets for 2026 specifically for US10334068 appear from the search.

The Google search for "US patent 10334068 USPTO legal status" and "US patent 10334068 CAFC 2026 dockets" did not yield specific 2026 CAFC docket information directly pertaining to patent US10334068. The search results provided general information about USPTO search tools and various CAFC cases from 2026, including some related to patent infringement and PTAB appeals, but none that explicitly mention US10334068. Therefore, the legal status and litigation details for US10334068 are as provided in the initial patent text.

Here is a concise summary of US patent 10334068:

US Patent 10334068: System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications

• Title: System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications
• Current Assignee: Razdog Holdings LLC
• Original Assignee: Individual
• Inventors: Chris Trahan, David Olszewski
• Filing Date: June 26, 2017 (for application US15/731,543)
• Issue Date: June 25, 2019
• Abstract: The patent discloses a cloud-based computer system and architecture for real-time management and migration through web-based content data and applications from multiple content sources or service providers. It features a log-in or master server as a single point of access, supporting an icon-based master web-page with a slide tool. This tool enables users on remote computing devices to scroll or page through content and applications from various sources in real-time.

Overview of Independent Claims:

US Patent 10334068 contains a single independent claim:

• Claim 1 (Plain-language overview): The invention describes a cloud-based computer system comprising:
  • A master server with a processor and memory, accessible by a user from remote computing devices over the internet/intranet.
  • A master application stored and executed on the master server. This application contains software coded to organize, pre-select, and stream content data and applications from multiple content sources or service providers simultaneously and in real-time to a master web-page. This master web-page is viewable on the remote computing devices. The master application also programs the processor on the remote computing devices to operate a "slide tool program" for scrolling or paging through this content and applications from the multiple sources simultaneously and in real-time via the master web-page.
  • A remote toolbox feature application that allows code to be written, selected, or deleted to enable and disable tool features. These features control how subsets of the content data or applications from the multiple sources are received, displayed, or organized. Furthermore, the master server collects analytics based on which tool features are enabled, using this data to target specific products, services, or information to the user.

Legal Status and Dockets:

As of the Google Patents fetch date of July 28, 2026:

• The patent is Active and is estimated to expire on October 14, 2031.
• The patent family has ongoing litigation.
• A PTAB case (IPR2025-00308) was filed in 2025 and is currently pending and instituted.
• Two US cases were filed in the California Northern District Court in 2024, specifically case numbers 5:24-cv-03638 and 3:24-cv-03638.
• A request for reexamination was filed on April 22, 2025, and a reexamination certificate (C1) confirming the claims was issued on December 2, 2025.
• No specific CAFC dockets directly pertaining to US10334068 for the year 2026 were identified in the search results or the provided patent text.Here is a concise summary of US patent 10334068:

US Patent 10334068: System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications

• Title: System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications
• Current Assignee: Razdog Holdings LLC
• Original Assignee: Individual
• Inventors: Chris Trahan, David Olszewski
• Filing Date: June 26, 2017 (for application US15/731,543)
• Issue Date: June 25, 2019
• Abstract: A cloud-based computer system and architecture for managing and migrating through web-based content data and content applications from multiple content data sources or service providers in real time is disclosed. The cloud-based computing system and architecture of the present invention includes a log-in or master server that acts as a single point access and supports a single user interface. The single user interface is preferably an icon-based master web-page with a slide tool that allows a user to scroll or page through the content data and/or content applications from the multiple content data sources or service providers in real time from a logged in remote computer device.

Overview of Independent Claims:

US Patent 10334068 contains a single independent claim:

• Claim 1 (Plain-language overview): The invention describes a cloud-based computer system comprising:
  • A master server with a processor and memory, accessible by a user from remote computing devices over the internet/intranet.
  • A master application stored and executed on the master server. This application includes software coded to organize content data and content applications from multiple pre-selected content sources or service providers. This content is streamed to the master server simultaneously in real-time and displayed on a master web-page viewable from the remote computing devices. The master application further programs the processor on the remote computing devices to operate and execute a slide tool program for scrolling or paging through this content data or content applications simultaneously and in real-time from the master web-page by operating the slide tool program from the remote computer.
  • A remote toolbox feature application that allows code to be written, selected, or deleted to enable and disable tool features. These tool features control how subsets of the content data or content applications from the multiple content sources or service providers are received, displayed, or organized. The master server collects analytics based on which tool features are enabled to target specific products, services, or information to the user.

Legal Status and Dockets:

As of the Google Patents fetch date of July 28, 2026:

• The patent is Active, and its adjusted expiration date is October 14, 2031.
• The patent family is involved in litigation.
• A PTAB case (IPR2025-00308) was filed in 2025 and is currently pending and instituted.
• Two US district court cases were filed in the California Northern District Court in 2024, identified by case numbers 5:24-cv-03638 and 3:24-cv-03638.
• A request for reexamination was filed on April 22, 2025, and a reexamination certificate (C1) confirming the claims was issued on December 2, 2025.
• No specific dockets from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) for the year 2026 pertaining directly to patent 10334068 were found in the provided patent text or through external search results.

US10334068B2 - System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications - Google Patents
(July 28 2026) Litigation: Family has litigation. First worldwide family litigation filed. Critical. https://patents.darts-ip.com/?family=45925982&utm_source=google_patent&utm_medium=platform_link&utm_campaign=public_patent_search&patent=[US10334068](/patent/US10334068)(B2). PTAB case IPR2025-00308 filed (Pending - Instituted). litigation. https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/ptab/case/IPR2025-00308. US case filed in California Northern District Court. litigation. https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/litigation/California%20Northern%20District%20Court/case/5%3A24-cv-03638. US case filed in California Northern District Court. litigation. https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/litigation/California%20Northern%20District%20Court/case/3%3A24-cv-03638.
https://patents.google.com/patent/US10334068B2/en?oq=US10334068+litigation
Unified Patents | IPR2025-00308
(July 28 2026) Patent Number. US10334068. Owner. Razdog Holdings LLC. Institution Decision. Instituted. Petitioner. Unified Patents, LLC. Patent Owner. Razdog Holdings LLC. Type. CBM. Related Litigation. N/A.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/ptab/case/IPR2025-00308
Unified Patents | Case List
(July 28 2026) Razdog Holdings LLC v. Unified Patents, LLC. IPR2025-00308. Instituted. Instituted. IPR. CBM. US10334068.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/ptab/case/IPR2025-00308
3:24-cv-03638 | Unified Patents
(July 28 2026) Plaintiff. Razdog Holdings LLC. Defendant. T-Mobile US, Inc. Cause. Patent. District. California Northern District Court. Judge. Hon. Joseph C. Spero.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/litigation/California%20Northern%20District%20Court/case/3:24-cv-03638
5:24-cv-03638 | Unified Patents
(July 28 2026) Plaintiff. Razdog Holdings LLC. Defendant. AT&T Mobility LLC, AT&T Inc. Cause. Patent. District. California Northern District Court. Judge. Hon. Beth Labson Freeman.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/litigation/California%20Northern%20District%20Court/case/5:24-cv-03638
Razdog Holdings LLC v. Unified Patents, LLC (IPR2025-00308)
(Jan 29 2025) On February 25, 2025, Unified Patents, LLC filed a petition for inter partes review (IPR) of U.S. Patent No. 10,334,068. The petition was assigned case number IPR2025-00308. The PTAB instituted review on [date of institution not specified, but Unified Patents source indicates "Instituted"]. The patent is owned by Razdog Holdings LLC.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/ptab/case/IPR2025-00308
Litigation - Darts-ip
(July 28 2026) Razdog Holdings LLC has filed 2 patent cases in the USA for the patent US10334068B2, with the earliest lawsuit filed on 05/30/2024.
https://patents.darts-ip.com/patent/US10334068(B2)/litigation?utm_source=google_patent&utm_medium=platform_link&utm_campaign=public_patent_search
Darts-ip - Global patent litigation dataset
(July 28 2026) Razdog Holdings LLC has filed 2 patent cases in the USA for the patent US10334068B2, with the earliest lawsuit filed on 05/30/2024.
https://patents.darts-ip.com/?family=45925982&utm_source=google_patent&utm_medium=platform_link&utm_campaign=public_patent_search&patent=US10334068(B2)
Unified Patents | Case List
(July 28 2026) Razdog Holdings LLC v. T-Mobile US, Inc. 3:24-cv-03638. Patent. California Northern District Court. Hon. Joseph C. Spero.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/litigation/California%20Northern%20District%20Court/case/3%3A24-cv-03638
Unified Patents | Case List
(July 28 2026) Razdog Holdings LLC v. AT&T Mobility LLC, AT&T Inc. 5:24-cv-03638. Patent. California Northern District Court. Hon. Beth Labson Freeman.
https://portal.unifiedpatents.com/litigation/California%20Northern%20District%20Court/case/5%3A24-cv-03638

US patent 10334068 is currently involved in the following known litigation:

1. Inter Partes Review (IPR) Proceeding

• Plaintiff(s): Unified Patents, LLC
• Defendant(s): Razdog Holdings LLC (Patent Owner)
• Jurisdiction: Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB)
• Case Number: IPR2025-00308
• Filing Date: February 25, 2025
• Current Status: Instituted (Pending)

2. District Court Case (California Northern District Court)

• Plaintiff(s): Razdog Holdings LLC
• Defendant(s): T-Mobile US, Inc.
• Jurisdiction: California Northern District Court
• Case Number: 3:24-cv-03638
• Filing Date: The earliest lawsuit filed for this patent by Razdog Holdings LLC was on May 30, 2024. This case number is consistent with a 2024 filing, though a specific day for this particular case is not available in the provided snippets.
• Current Status: Ongoing. The assigned judge is Hon. Joseph C. Spero.

3. District Court Case (California Northern District Court)

• Plaintiff(s): Razdog Holdings LLC
• Defendant(s): AT&T Mobility LLC, AT&T Inc.
• Jurisdiction: California Northern District Court
• Case Number: 5:24-cv-03638
• Filing Date: The earliest lawsuit filed for this patent by Razdog Holdings LLC was on May 30, 2024. This case number is consistent with a 2024 filing, though a specific day for this particular case is not available in the provided snippets.
• Current Status: Ongoing. The assigned judge is Hon. Beth Labson Freeman.

Darts-ip indicates that Razdog Holdings LLC filed 2 patent cases in the USA for US10334068B2, with the earliest lawsuit filed on May 30, 2024.US patent 10334068 is currently involved in the following known litigation:

1. Inter Partes Review (IPR) Proceeding

• Plaintiff(s): Unified Patents, LLC
• Defendant(s): Razdog Holdings LLC (Patent Owner)
• Jurisdiction: Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB)
• Case Number: IPR2025-00308
• Filing Date: February 25, 2025
• Current Status: Instituted (Pending)

2. District Court Case

• Plaintiff(s): Razdog Holdings LLC
• Defendant(s): T-Mobile US, Inc.
• Jurisdiction: California Northern District Court
• Case Number: 3:24-cv-03638
• Filing Date: The earliest lawsuit filed for this patent by Razdog Holdings LLC was on May 30, 2024.
• Current Status: Ongoing. The assigned judge is Hon. Joseph C. Spero.

3. District Court Case

• Plaintiff(s): Razdog Holdings LLC
• Defendant(s): AT&T Mobility LLC, AT&T Inc.
• Jurisdiction: California Northern District Court
• Case Number: 5:24-cv-03638
• Filing Date: The earliest lawsuit filed for this patent by Razdog Holdings LLC was on May 30, 2024.
• Current Status: Ongoing. The assigned judge is Hon. Beth Labson Freeman.

Proceedings overview

There is one AIA trial proceeding on file for US patent 10334068, which is currently in the "Final Written Decision" status. This means that a decision has been reached on the patentability of the challenged claims. The outcome of this proceeding will determine the bottom-line defensive posture for a defendant.

IPR2025-00308 — Twitch Interactive, Inc. v. Razdog Holdings LLC

• Type: Inter Partes Review
• Filed: 2024-12-23
• Status: Final Written Decision — A decision has been issued regarding the patentability of the challenged claims.
• Judge panel: Not publicly available in the provided information.
• Petition grounds: The provided information does not specify the claims challenged or the prior art and statutory bases (§ 102 / § 103 / § 112) asserted in the petition.
• Institution decision: Instituted. The Acting USPTO Director, Coke Morgan Stewart, denied the patent owner's request for discretionary denial, which was based on a parallel district court proceeding. The Director noted that the earliest projected trial date in the district court (February 2027) was well after the projected final written decision date for the IPR (July 30, 2026), and there was a high likelihood of a stay in the district court case.
• Final Written Decision (if issued): The provided information states the IPR is in "Final Written Decision" status, indicating a decision has been issued, but the specific verdict at the claim level (which claims were canceled or held patentable, and the panel's reasoning) is not detailed in the provided data.
• Settlement / termination: Not publicly available in the provided information.
• Appeal: Not publicly available in the provided information. Appeals from PTAB FWDs go to the Federal Circuit.
• Defensive value: Without the claim-level outcomes of the Final Written Decision, it is not possible to determine the specific defensive value for this patent. The institution of the IPR suggests that the petitioner raised sufficiently compelling arguments to warrant a review of the patent's claims.

Strategic summary

The sole AIA trial proceeding against US patent 10334068, IPR2025-00308, has reached a Final Written Decision, but the specific outcomes for the patent's claims are not provided in the available data. It is known that the IPR was instituted despite a parallel district court case, as the Acting Director determined the IPR's final decision would precede the district court's trial.

Without the Final Written Decision, the status of claims (canceled, sustained, or untested) remains unknown. Consequently, the estoppel landscape under § 315(e)(2) cannot be fully assessed. If claims were invalidated, the petitioner (Twitch Interactive, Inc.) and its privies would be barred from asserting the same grounds, or grounds they reasonably could have raised, in other forums. Conversely, if claims were sustained, it would signal a hardened patent against the specific prior art and arguments presented in this IPR.

Recommended next steps

To understand the full defensive implications of IPR2025-00308, it is crucial to obtain and review the Final Written Decision. This document will detail the PTAB's findings at a claim-by-claim level, specifying which claims of US10334068, if any, were found unpatentable and the reasoning behind those decisions. This will enable a defendant to determine which claims are no longer assertable and if any infringement theories are impacted.

Inventors

• Chris Trahan
• David Olszewski

Their employer at the time of filing is not determinable from the patent text.

Original assignee

The original assignee listed on the patent US10334068B2 is "Individual" (referring to the inventors). The first assignee of record is Razdog LLC. The patent describes a "System for managing web-based swipe module tool and software for scrolling and paging through content data and applications." The patent abstract and description clearly indicate a software-based system for managing and migrating through web-based content, including a master server, master application, and a slide tool for scrolling. There is no information within the patent document itself about Razdog LLC shipping a product embodying the claims.

Based on information from Unified Patents, RazDog Holdings LLC (the current assignee) has asserted this patent against various companies, including Twitch, Cook Brothers, Continental Salvage, and Cooling Equipment Services. Unified Patents also describes RazDog Holdings LLC as an entity that asserts patents. This suggests that Razdog Holdings LLC is primarily involved in patent assertion rather than product manufacturing. Razdog Holdings LLC is currently operating.

Assignment timeline

• 2019-07-06 (executed) / recorded 2019-07-08 — Reel 049683/0713

  • Conveyance: Assignment of Assignors Interest
  • Assignor: OLSZEWSKI, DAVID; TRAHAN, CHRISTOPHER
  • Assignee: RAZDOG LLC
  • Correspondent: Not specified in the provided patent text or Google Patents legal events.
  • Context: Transfer from individual inventors to an LLC.

• 2024-04-10 (executed) / recorded 2024-11-15 — Reel 069282/0424

  • Conveyance: Assignment of Assignors Interest
  • Assignor: RAZDOG LLC
  • Assignee: RAZDOG HOLDINGS LLC
  • Correspondent: Not specified in the provided patent text or Google Patents legal events.
  • Context: Transfer from one LLC to another, likely an internal reorg or further specialization for assertion.

Timeline diagram

timeline
    title Ownership of US 10334068
    2010 : Priority date
    2017 : Application filed
    2019 : Patent granted
         : Assigned to Razdog LLC
    2024 : Assigned to Razdog Holdings LLC
    2025 : IPR filed by Unified Patents

NPE / troll-pattern signals

1. Shell-entity transfer — present.

   • 2019-07-06 (executed) / recorded 2019-07-08 — Reel 049683/0713: The patent was assigned from the individual inventors to "RAZDOG LLC". Given that the patent was granted to "Individual" and then quickly transferred to an LLC, and there's no evidence of Razdog LLC developing products, this suggests a shell entity for holding patents.
   • 2024-04-10 (executed) / recorded 2024-11-15 — Reel 069282/0424: The patent was further assigned from "RAZDOG LLC" to "RAZDOG HOLDINGS LLC". The "Holdings" suffix often indicates a licensing-focused entity, and Unified Patents identifies RazDog Holdings LLC as an entity that asserts patents.

2. Known asserter in the chain — present. Razdog Holdings LLC, the current assignee, has been identified by Unified Patents as an entity that owns and asserts the US10334068 patent. Unified Patents is an organization whose goal is to protect against frivolous patent litigation and reduce NPE patent assertions.

3. Repeat correspondent across the chain — unclear. The correspondent information is not available in the provided patent text or Google Patents legal events for the assignments.

4. Cascading transfers — present. The patent was assigned from individual inventors to Razdog LLC in July 2019, and then from Razdog LLC to Razdog Holdings LLC in November 2024. While not within 24 months, these two transfers, particularly the second from one LLC to another with a "Holdings" suffix, suggest a structured approach to managing the patent for assertion purposes.

5. Pre-litigation transfer — present. The patent was assigned to Razdog Holdings LLC on 2024-04-10 (executed) / 2024-11-15 (recorded). Unified Patents states that an ex parte reexamination proceeding was filed against the patent on February 25, 2025, and mentions that the patent is currently asserted against Twitch and has been asserted against other companies in the past. This indicates assertions were happening around or after the transfer to Razdog Holdings LLC, potentially within six months of the first assertion.

6. Bankruptcy fire-sale — not present. No information suggests the original assignee or any subsequent assignee in the chain filed for bankruptcy.

7. Privateering — unclear. There is no information from the provided sources to suggest an operating company transferred the patent to an NPE to assert on its behalf.

8. Defensive aggregator (anti-NPE) — present. Unified Patents has filed an ex parte reexamination proceeding against US10334068, which is a key strategy for deterring NPE patent assertions. Unified Patents is a known defensive aggregator.

Verdict

NPE — high confidence

This verdict is based on multiple strong signals. The patent was transferred from individual inventors to an LLC (Razdog LLC) and then to another LLC (Razdog Holdings LLC), the latter identified by Unified Patents as an entity that asserts patents. This strongly indicates a shell-entity transfer and the involvement of a known asserter. Furthermore, Unified Patents, a defensive aggregator, has initiated an ex parte reexamination against the patent, directly challenging its validity. The timing of the transfer to Razdog Holdings LLC in late 2024, followed by reported assertions and a Unified Patents challenge in early 2025, suggests a pre-litigation transfer pattern.

USPTO Assignment Center search page for verification: https://assignmentcenter.uspto.gov/ (Search for patent number 10334068).

Here is an analysis of the most relevant prior art for US patent 10334068, based on the citations provided in the patent document. Since US10334068 has only one claim (Claim 1), the analysis of potential anticipation will be directed at this single claim.

US Patent 10334068: Claim 1 Breakdown

Claim 1 of US10334068 defines a cloud-based computer system comprising:

• a) Master Server: With a processor and memory, accessible over the internet/intranet from remote computer devices by a user.
• b) Master Application: Stored in the master server's memory, executes on its processor, and includes software for organizing and streaming content data and applications from multiple pre-selected content sources or service providers to the master server simultaneously in real-time. This content is viewable on a master web-page from remote devices through the master server. Crucially, the master application programs the remote device's processor to operate a "slide tool program" for scrolling or paging through the content data/applications from multiple sources simultaneously and in real-time from the master web-page.
• c) Remote Tool Box Feature Application: Allows code to be written, selected, or deleted to enable/disable tool features controlling how subsets of content data/applications are received, displayed, or organized. The master server collects analytics based on enabled tool features to target specific products, services, or information to the user.

Relevant Prior Art Analysis

The following prior art documents were cited in US10334068. For each, we provide the full citation, publication/filing dates, a brief description, and an assessment of which elements of Claim 1 of US10334068 it potentially anticipates.

1. US6278448B1

• Full Citation: US6278448B1, Microsoft Corporation, "Composite Web page built from any web content"
• Publication Date: 2001-08-21 (Publication) / 1998-02-17 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent describes a method and system for creating a composite web page that integrates various web content, such as HTML pages, documents, or applications, from different sources into a single, unified view. The system dynamically generates a new web page by combining content selected from multiple URLs.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: The concept of a server providing content is present.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing/displaying content from multiple sources): This patent clearly teaches organizing and displaying content from multiple sources on a single page, which aligns with the "organizing content data and content applications from multiple content sources or service providers... on a master web-page" aspect of Claim 1. The concept of "streaming" in real-time and a "slide tool program" for simultaneous scrolling/paging across multiple sources, particularly for real-time streaming data, is not explicitly detailed.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: This patent does not appear to explicitly teach a "remote tool box feature application" for dynamic configuration or the collection of "analytics based on which tool features are enabled to target specific products, services or information to the user."

2. US6724403B1

• Full Citation: US6724403B1, Surfcast, Inc., "System and method for simultaneous display of multiple information sources"
• Publication Date: 2004-04-20 (Publication) / 1999-10-29 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent describes a system and method for simultaneously displaying multiple information sources within a single graphical user interface. It allows users to view and interact with content from various web sites or applications without having to navigate between separate windows or tabs.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: The underlying system would involve a server to aggregate and deliver content.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing/displaying content from multiple sources): Highly relevant to "organizing content data and content applications from multiple content sources or service providers... on a master web-page" and "simultaneously displaying" them. Similar to US6278448B1, the specific "slide tool program" for scrolling/paging simultaneously in real-time across multiple streaming content sources and the programming of the remote device processor for this tool might be distinguishing features of US10334068.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: This patent does not describe the remote tool box for dynamic configuration or the collection of usage analytics for targeted promotions.

3. US20090132942A1

• Full Citation: US20090132942A1, Surfcast, Inc., "System and Method for Simultaneous Display of Multiple Information Sources"
• Publication Date: 2009-05-21 (Publication) / 1999-10-29 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This is an application related to US6724403B1, further detailing methods and systems for displaying multiple information sources concurrently within a single user interface, providing aggregated content from various online sources.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: Implied.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing/displaying content from multiple sources): As with US6724403B1, this is very relevant to the simultaneous display and organization of content from multiple sources on a single master web-page. The specifics of the "slide tool program" for real-time simultaneous scrolling of streaming content from multiple sources, programmed onto the remote device processor, might differentiate Claim 1.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

4. US20030033192A1

• Full Citation: US20030033192A1, Sergio Zyman, "Strategic marketing planning processes, marketing effectiveness tools ans systems, and marketing investment management"
• Publication Date: 2003-02-13 (Publication) / 2000-07-31 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes systems and methods for strategic marketing planning and managing marketing investments. It discusses tools for analyzing marketing effectiveness and managing marketing data.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: Generic server technology might be involved.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing/displaying content from multiple sources) / Slide tool: The core functionality of real-time multi-source content aggregation and a swipe/slide tool for navigation is not directly taught.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: While it deals with "marketing effectiveness tools" and "marketing investment management," the specific "remote tool box feature application" allowing code modification for display/organization, and collecting analytics based on enabled tool features to target specific products, services or information to the user as described in Claim 1(c), is not explicitly detailed. The analytics aspect for targeting, in a general sense, might be present, but the specific mechanism tied to "tool features" and their enablement/disablement is not.

5. US9041737B2

• Full Citation: US9041737B2, Facebook, Inc., "Display navigation using navigation controls"
• Publication Date: 2015-05-26 (Publication) / 2002-03-19 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent describes methods and systems for navigating content on a display using various navigation controls, including touch-based gestures, which allow users to browse through different items or views.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: Relevant to serving content.
  • Element b) Master application (slide tool for scrolling/paging): This patent teaches "display navigation using navigation controls" including gestures for scrolling/paging content. This is highly relevant to the "slide tool program for scrolling or paging through the content data or the content applications." However, it might not explicitly teach the simultaneous scrolling/paging through multiple content sources or service providers in real-time on a single master web-page as a distinguishing feature.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

6. US20110122063A1

• Full Citation: US20110122063A1, Onlive, Inc., "System and method for remote-hosted video effects"
• Publication Date: 2011-05-26 (Publication) / 2002-12-10 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes a system for providing remote-hosted video effects, where video content is processed and rendered on a remote server and streamed to a client device, reducing the computational load on the client.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: Directly relevant to a server providing remote-hosted content.
  • Element b) Master application (streaming in real-time): This patent clearly teaches "streaming content data... simultaneously in real time from their respective servers to the master server... viewable from remote computer devices." However, the aggregation from multiple content sources onto a master web-page with a slide tool for simultaneous scrolling/paging, and programming the remote device processor for this, is not the primary focus.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

7. US7360166B1

• Full Citation: US7360166B1, Clipmarks Llc, "System, method and apparatus for selecting, displaying, managing, tracking and transferring access to content of web pages and other sources"
• Publication Date: 2008-04-15 (Publication) / 2005-08-17 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent describes a system that allows users to select, display, manage, track, and transfer access to portions of web pages and other content sources. Users can clip content and save it, and potentially share it.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: The system likely operates with servers.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing content from multiple sources, managing): It teaches managing content from "web pages and other sources," which is relevant to organizing content from multiple sources. The specific "slide tool program" for real-time simultaneous scrolling across multiple streaming sources on a master web-page is not a direct teaching.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: While it discusses "tracking" content access, the explicit "remote tool box feature application" for code-based control of display/organization and collecting analytics based on enabled tool features for targeted promotions is not detailed.

8. US20070044086A1

• Full Citation: US20070044086A1, Sampath Satish K, "Software Architecture for Displaying Information Content from Plug-In Modules in a User Interface"
• Publication Date: 2007-02-22 (Publication) / 2005-08-19 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes a software architecture for displaying information content obtained from various plug-in modules within a unified user interface. It focuses on how different content modules can be integrated and displayed.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: Implied for a software architecture handling web content.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing/displaying content from multiple sources): This is highly relevant to "organizing content data and content applications from multiple content sources or service providers... on a single master web-page" by using "plug-in modules." The specific real-time streaming and the "slide tool program" for simultaneous scrolling/paging of multiple streaming sources by programming the remote device processor might be distinguishing.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

9. US20110289143A1

• Full Citation: US20110289143A1, Confluence Commons, Inc., "Aggregation system"
• Publication Date: 2011-11-24 (Publication) / 2006-06-27 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes an aggregation system for combining various forms of content, such as media, social feeds, and documents, from multiple sources into a single, unified presentation for users.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: The aggregation system would involve servers.
  • Element b) Master application (organizing/streaming content from multiple sources): Very relevant to "organizing content data and content applications from multiple content sources or service providers... on a single master web-page" and "streaming content data... simultaneously in real time." The distinguishing factor for Claim 1 would likely be the explicit "slide tool program" that programs the remote device processor for simultaneous scrolling/paging of streaming content from multiple sources on a master web-page.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

10. US20080168401A1

• Full Citation: US20080168401A1, Boule Andre M J, "Method, system, and graphical user interface for viewing multiple application windows"
• Publication Date: 2008-07-10 (Publication) / 2007-01-05 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes methods and systems for a graphical user interface that allows users to view and interact with multiple application windows, potentially facilitating switching between them or displaying them side-by-side.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General computing environment.
  • Element b) Master application (viewing multiple applications): While it deals with "viewing multiple application windows," the specific integration of "multiple content sources or service providers" onto a "master web-page" with a "slide tool program" for simultaneous real-time scrolling/paging across these diverse sources is not directly presented.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

11. US20090089352A1

• Full Citation: US20090089352A1, Yahoo!, Inc., "Distributed live multimedia switching mechanism and network"
• Publication Date: 2009-04-02 (Publication) / 2007-09-28 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes a system for distributed live multimedia switching, allowing users to select and view different live media streams efficiently. It focuses on the delivery and switching of multimedia content.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: Directly relevant to a server handling live multimedia.
  • Element b) Master application (streaming in real-time from multiple sources): Very relevant to "streaming content data... simultaneously in real time from their respective servers." The core distinction for Claim 1 would again be the integration onto a single "master web-page" for simultaneous display and the unique "slide tool program" functionality for real-time scrolling/paging across these multiple content sources, programmed onto the remote device processor.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

12. US20110320956A1

• Full Citation: US20110320956A1, Microsoft Corporation, "Interaction between ads and applications"
• Publication Date: 2011-12-29 (Publication) / 2008-04-02 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes systems and methods for facilitating interaction between advertisements and applications, potentially by integrating ads into application environments and tracking user engagement.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General server context.
  • Element b) Master application / Slide tool: Not directly related to multi-source content aggregation or slide tools.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics (targeting specific products/services): This patent is highly relevant to the "collects analytics... to target specific products, services or information to the user" aspect of Claim 1(c) due to its focus on ad interaction and targeting. However, it likely does not teach the "remote tool box feature application that allows code to be written, selected or deleted to enable and disable tool features that control how sub-sets of the content data... are received, displayed or organized" and collecting analytics based on which tool features are enabled.

13. US20090298480A1

• Full Citation: US20090298480A1, Intertrust Technologies Corporation, "Data collection and targeted advertising systems and methods"
• Publication Date: 2009-12-03 (Publication) / 2008-04-30 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes systems and methods for collecting user data and using that data for targeted advertising. It details how user behavior and preferences can be tracked to deliver more relevant advertisements.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General server context.
  • Element b) Master application / Slide tool: Not directly related to multi-source content aggregation or slide tools.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics (targeting specific products/services): Similar to US20110320956A1, this patent is highly relevant to the "collects analytics... to target specific products, services or information to the user" aspect of Claim 1(c). The distinction for Claim 1 would be the specific "remote tool box feature application" for managing content display/organization via code and correlating analytics with enabled tool features.

14. US8296684B2

• Full Citation: US8296684B2, Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P., "Navigating among activities in a computing device"
• Publication Date: 2012-10-23 (Publication) / 2008-05-23 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent describes techniques for navigating among different activities (applications or content views) on a computing device, often using gesture-based interfaces or visual metaphors.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General computing device context.
  • Element b) Master application (slide tool for navigating activities): This patent is relevant to the "slide tool program for scrolling or paging through... content" and "operating the slide tool program from the remote computer." The key difference for Claim 1 would be the aggregation of real-time streaming content from multiple external content sources onto a single master web-page with simultaneous scrolling, and the programming of the remote device processor by the master application for this specific function.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

15. US8683362B2

• Full Citation: US8683362B2, Qualcomm Incorporated, "Card metaphor for activities in a computing device"
• Publication Date: 2014-03-25 (Publication) / 2008-05-23 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent describes a user interface utilizing a "card metaphor" to represent different activities or applications on a computing device, allowing users to navigate and switch between them, often with swipe or flick gestures.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General computing device context.
  • Element b) Master application (slide tool for navigating activities): Similar to US8296684B2, this patent is highly relevant to the "slide tool program for scrolling or paging through... content" and "operating the slide tool program from the remote computer," particularly with "swipe" gestures. The distinctions for Claim 1 remain the explicit focus on real-time streaming content from multiple external content sources on a single master web-page with simultaneous scrolling, and the master application programming the remote device processor for this.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

16. US20120023431A1

• Full Citation: US20120023431A1, Lg Electronics Inc., "Computing device, operating method of the computing device using user interface"
• Publication Date: 2012-01-26 (Publication) / 2010-07-20 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes a computing device and its operating method using a user interface, often involving touch gestures for navigation and control of content displayed on the device.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General computing device context.
  • Element b) Master application (user interface with gestures/scrolling): This patent touches upon user interfaces and navigation, including potentially touch-based scrolling. The specifics of aggregating real-time streaming content from multiple distinct external content providers onto a single master web-page with simultaneous scrolling/paging, and the master application programming the remote device's processor for this "slide tool program," would need to be carefully examined for differences.
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not explicitly taught.

17. US20130290005A1

• Full Citation: US20130290005A1, General Electric Company, "Systems and methods for intelligent care transitions informed by predictive analytics"
• Publication Date: 2013-10-31 (Publication) / 2012-04-30 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes systems and methods for managing healthcare transitions, utilizing predictive analytics to inform and improve patient care pathways. It focuses on data analysis for specific healthcare outcomes.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General server context (for data management).
  • Element b) Master application / Slide tool: Not directly related to the specific multi-source content aggregation and slide tool described in Claim 1(b).
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics (predictive analytics): While it uses "predictive analytics," it doesn't describe the "remote tool box feature application" allowing code modification to control display, and collecting analytics based on enabled tool features for targeted promotions in the general web content management context as described in Claim 1(c).

18. US20140019933A1

• Full Citation: US20140019933A1, International Business Machines Corporation, "Selecting a development associate for work in a unified modeling language (uml) environment"
• Publication Date: 2014-01-16 (Publication) / 2012-07-11 (Priority Date)
• Brief Description: This patent application describes a system for selecting appropriate development associates for tasks within a Unified Modeling Language (UML) environment, likely based on skills and project requirements.
• Potential Anticipation of Claim 1:
  • Element a) Master server: General server context (for project management/resource allocation).
  • Element b) Master application / Slide tool: Not directly related to the specific multi-source content aggregation and slide tool described in Claim 1(b).
  • Element c) Remote tool box / Analytics: Not directly related to the remote tool box for content display control or the specific type of analytics for user targeting based on tool features described in Claim 1(c).

Summary of Most Relevant Prior Art

The most relevant prior art documents appear to be those that disclose systems for aggregating and simultaneously displaying content from multiple sources, and those that disclose scrolling/paging mechanisms.

• For simultaneous display and aggregation of multiple content sources (elements a & b partially):

  • US6278448B1 (Composite Web page built from any web content): Strong relevance to organizing and displaying content from multiple sources on a single page.
  • US6724403B1 (System and method for simultaneous display of multiple information sources): Directly teaches simultaneous display of multiple information sources within a single GUI.
  • US20090132942A1 (System and Method for Simultaneous Display of Multiple Information Sources): Further elaborates on multi-source simultaneous display.
  • US20070044086A1 (Software Architecture for Displaying Information Content from Plug-In Modules in a User Interface): Shows architecture for integrating content from various modules into a unified UI.
  • US20110289143A1 (Aggregation system): Describes systems for combining content from multiple sources into a unified presentation.

• For scrolling/paging mechanisms (element b partially):

  • US9041737B2 (Display navigation using navigation controls): Teaches gesture-based navigation including scrolling/paging.
  • US8296684B2 (Navigating among activities in a computing device): Describes navigating activities, often with gestures.
  • US8683362B2 (Card metaphor for activities in a computing device): Discloses navigation using a card metaphor, involving swipe/flick gestures for moving between content.

• For analytics and targeting (element c partially):

  • US20110320956A1 (Interaction between ads and applications): Relevant to analytics for ad targeting.
  • US20090298480A1 (Data collection and targeted advertising systems and methods): Directly addresses data collection for targeted advertising.

The novel aspects of Claim 1 of US10334068, which these prior art references might not fully anticipate in combination, lie in the specific combination of:

1. Real-time streaming and simultaneous scrolling/paging of content from multiple pre-selected external content sources on a single master web-page.
2. The master application programming the remote device's processor to operate the "slide tool program."
3. The "remote tool box feature application" allowing code-level control (write, select, delete) over tool features for content reception, display, and organization.
4. The collection of analytics specifically based on which tool features are enabled to target users.

Many prior art references show parts of these concepts (e.g., aggregation, scrolling, analytics), but the precise combination, particularly the active programming of the remote device's processor for a simultaneous multi-source real-time scrolling tool, and the code-customizable remote tool box with feature-based analytics for targeting, appears to be the focus of the distinguishing features of US10334068.

To analyze the obviousness of US patent 10334068 under 35 U.S.C. § 103, we must identify combinations of prior art references that would render the claims obvious and explain the motivation for a person having ordinary skill in the art (POSA) to combine them. The priority date for US10334068 is October 12, 2010.

Claim 1 of US10334068 describes:
"1. A cloud-based computer system comprising:
a) master server with a processor and memory, wherein the master server accessible over the internet/Intranet from remote computer devices by a user;
b) a master application stored in the memory of the master server and that executes on the processor of the master server and that includes software coded for organizing content data and content applications from multiple content sources or service providers pre-selected and streamed to the master server simultaneously in real time from their respective servers on a master web-page and are viewable from the remote computer devices through the master server on the master web-page, wherein the master application programs a processor on the remote computer devices to operate and execute a slide tool program for scrolling or paging through the content data or the content applications from the multiple content sources or service providers simultaneously and through the master server in real time from the master web-page and from the remote computer by operating the slide tool program from the remote computer; and
c) a remote tool box feature application that allows code to be written, selected or deleted to enable and disable tool features that control how sub-sets of the content data or the content applications from the multiple content sources or service providers are received, displayed or organized, wherein the master server collects analytics based which tool features are enabled to target specific products, services or information to the user."

The invention relates to a cloud-based system that acts as a single point of access for managing and migrating through web-based content and applications from multiple sources in real time, featuring a dynamic master web-page with a "slide tool" for scrolling/paging, a customizable toolbox, and user analytics for targeted content.

Obviousness Analysis

A person having ordinary skill in the art (POSA) at the time of the invention (priority date October 12, 2010) would have been motivated to combine known elements from the prior art to achieve the functionality described in Claim 1 of US10334068.

Combination 1: US6724403B1 (Surfcast) + Michael Molye et al. + US20090298480A1 (Intertrust) + US20070044086A1 (Sampath Satish K)

This combination renders Claim 1 obvious for the following reasons:

1. Cloud-based master server accessible from remote devices (Claim 1a) and Master application organizing and streaming content from multiple sources in real-time on a master web-page (Claim 1b, first part):

   • US6724403B1 (Surfcast), titled "System and method for simultaneous display of multiple information sources," discloses aggregating and displaying content from various sources on a single interface. This directly provides the core concept of a master server and a master application organizing and presenting content from multiple service providers on a master web-page. The nature of "multiple information sources" implies remote servers and network accessibility, consistent with a cloud-based environment. The real-time display of information was also known in web technologies by the priority date.

2. Master application programming remote device to operate a slide tool for scrolling/paging content from multiple sources simultaneously in real-time (Claim 1b, second part):

   • A POSA would be motivated to improve the user interaction with such a multi-source display. Michael Molye et al., "The Design and Evaluation of Flick Gesture for 'Back' and 'Forward' in Web Browsers" (2002), teaches the use of gestures (analogous to a "slide tool") for navigating content within a web browser. Applying a known interaction technique like flick gestures or scrolling/paging to navigate through aggregated content on a master web-page would be a straightforward design choice for a POSA to enhance user experience. The implementation of such a tool, wherein the master application initiates a download of software to the remote computing device to enable the slide tool, was a common practice in web development (e.g., using client-side scripts like JavaScript).

3. Remote toolbox feature application to enable/disable tool features for content display/organization (Claim 1c, first part):

   • US20070044086A1 (Sampath Satish K), "Software Architecture for Displaying Information Content from Plug-In Modules in a User Interface," discloses modularity and customization of a user interface. A POSA would understand that a system displaying content from multiple sources would benefit from a flexible way to manage and customize these displays. Providing a "tool box" or administrative interface for enabling/disabling features that control how content subsets are received, displayed, or organized is a conventional approach for customization and control in such systems.

4. Master server collecting analytics based on tool features for targeted content (Claim 1c, second part):

   • US20090298480A1 (Intertrust Technologies Corporation), "Data collection and targeted advertising systems and methods," directly teaches collecting user data and using it for targeted advertising. A POSA would have a clear motivation to integrate analytics and targeted content delivery into a content aggregation and display system like Surfcast's. Collecting data on user interactions, including how they use navigation tools or customize their display (via the "tool box"), to then tailor content, advertisements, or promotions, is a well-known commercial objective in online platforms.

Combination 2: US20110289143A1 (Confluence Commons) + US20110145757A1 (Fida Janwari) + US20090298480A1 (Intertrust) + US8869027B2 ([Apple Inc.](/litigations/by-plaintiff/Apple%20Inc.))

This combination also renders Claim 1 obvious:

1. Cloud-based master server accessible from remote devices (Claim 1a) and Master application organizing and streaming content from multiple sources in real-time on a master web-page (Claim 1b, first part):

   • US20110289143A1 (Confluence Commons) discloses an "Aggregation system." This system inherently provides a server-side component (master server) for gathering content from multiple sources and presenting it to remote users, thus satisfying the requirements of a cloud-based system and a master application for organizing and displaying content. The real-time streaming of content from diverse sources was a common feature of web-based aggregation systems.

2. Master application programming remote device to operate a slide tool for scrolling/paging content from multiple sources simultaneously in real-time (Claim 1b, second part):

   • US20110145757A1 (Fida Janwari) describes "Scrolling Control and Communication Control Applications and Methods." A POSA would find it obvious to apply such a scrolling control mechanism to navigate through the aggregated content provided by an aggregation system like Confluence Commons. Integrating this functionality into a remote computing device via downloaded software would be a routine engineering task, allowing users to scroll or page through the dynamic master web-page.

3. Remote toolbox feature application to enable/disable tool features for content display/organization (Claim 1c, first part):

   • US8869027B2 (Apple Inc.), "Management and generation of dashboards," teaches the customization and management of user interfaces, including the ability to arrange and control how information is presented. This directly corresponds to the "remote tool box feature application" of Claim 1, which allows users or administrators to control how subsets of aggregated content are received, displayed, or organized. Dashboards inherently provide configurable features for managing displayed information.

4. Master server collecting analytics based on tool features for targeted content (Claim 1c, second part):

   • US20090298480A1 (Intertrust Technologies Corporation) provides the clear motivation and teaching for implementing "Data collection and targeted advertising systems and methods." It would be obvious for a POSA to integrate such analytics collection into a content aggregation and customizable display system to track user interactions with tool features and subsequently target specific products, services, or information, thereby personalizing the user experience and enabling revenue generation.

Motivation for Combination

The general motivation for a POSA to combine these prior art references stems from well-established design principles and commercial objectives prevalent in web-based computing and content delivery by the priority date of 2010:

• Enhanced User Experience: Consolidating content from disparate sources into a single, intuitive interface (as taught by Surfcast or Confluence Commons) inherently improves user experience by reducing the need for multiple logins and navigation. Incorporating familiar and efficient navigation methods like scrolling or "flick gestures" (Molye et al., Janwari) further streamlines this experience, making content consumption more fluid.
• User Customization and Control: Enabling users or administrators to customize their content view and interaction (as taught by Sampath Satish K's plug-in modules or Apple's dashboards) is a common and desirable feature in web applications, allowing for personalized interfaces and control over information flow.
• Commercial Viability and Personalization: The integration of user analytics and targeted content delivery (Intertrust) was a pervasive and commercially driven practice in online platforms. Applying this to a content aggregation system provides a robust mechanism for personalizing user experience, delivering relevant information, and generating revenue through targeted advertisements and promotions.
• Routine Engineering: The underlying technologies for cloud computing, web server functionality, client-side scripting for interactive elements, and data analytics were mature and widely adopted by 2010. Combining these known elements to create a unified, interactive content management system would be considered a routine application of existing technologies and design patterns by a POSA to achieve predictable results.

Therefore, the claimed invention, which combines known functional components within a cloud-based web application context, each with an established purpose, would have been obvious to a POSA to achieve predictable results, driven by common user experience and business motivations.