Invalidity dossier
US 7236547
Added 8/27/2026, 2:01:33 AM
Active provider: DeepSeek · deepseek-v4-flash
Auto-generating section 1 of 7: Litigation summary…
Each section takes ~30-60s with web-search grounding. Keep this tab open — sections will fill in below as they complete.
Patent summary
Title, assignee, inventors, filing/issue dates, abstract, and a plain-language overview of the claims.
US Patent 7,236,547 — Summary
Bibliographic Data
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Patent number | US 7,236,547 B2 (application no. 11/088,116) |
| Title | Start-up automatic frequency control (AFC) method and apparatus |
| Inventor | Alpaslan Demir |
| Assignee (original) | InterDigital Technology Corp. (Wilmington, DE) |
| Filing date | March 23, 2005 |
| Issue (grant) date | June 26, 2007 |
| Priority date | July 31, 2002 (provisional 60/399,818) |
| Parent case | Continuation of U.S. 10/629,429 (issued as U.S. 7,187,732) |
| Current status | Expired — lapsed for failure to pay maintenance fees (effective June 26, 2019); "Expired – Fee Related" per USPTO records |
| Claims | 22 total (5 independent: claims 1, 7, 10, 13, 22) |
Abstract (as published)
"Method and apparatus for adjusting the frequency of a voltage controlled oscillator (VCO) at a receiver to synchronize the receiver with the transmitter by correlating a synchronization code channel with training sequences to estimate positive and negative offsets which are employed to estimate an error, which is then filtered. The filter output provides voltage controlling the VCO. The same technique may be employed to control a numeric controlled oscillator (NCO)."
Technology in Plain Language
During initial cell search (ICS) at UE power-up in a TDD/cellular system, the receiver must correct a potentially large carrier-frequency offset (up to ~6 kHz) before it can complete Step 1/2/3 cell-search processing. The patent's "start-up AFC" uses a phase-rotation correlation approach: a stored PSC sequence is rotated by +3 kHz and −3 kHz, each rotated version is correlated against the received sequence, and the absolute values (a, b) of the two correlations are combined into a frequency-error estimate. That error is filtered (a proportional-plus-integral, PI, filter) and drives a VCO/NCO to pull the receiver frequency into lock (nominally from 6 kHz down to <2 kHz). Step 1 cell search runs in parallel to keep refreshing the PSC peak location, since frequency correction shifts the code timing.
Independent Claims — Plain-Language Overview
Claim 1 (broadest): A start-up AFC method during initial cell search by a UE receiver: (a) receive input containing a sequence; (b) rotate a stored sequence's phase by a given frequency in both the positive and negative directions; (c) correlate the received sequence with the positively rotated sequence; (d) correlate with the negatively rotated sequence; (e) combine the two correlation outputs into a frequency control signal and auto-adjust the UE receiver's frequency; and repeat (b)–(e) every N frames (N ≥ 1) to process the PSC on the PSCH for SCH-location determination during ICS.
Claim 7: Adds a specific combining formula to claim 1's step (e): take absolute values of the two correlations (a, b) and compute the error as 6 kHz × [(a − b) ÷ (a + b + c)], where c is a constant (used to avoid division by zero).
Claim 10: Adds power-level control to claim 1: the received input power level is adjusted prior to step (a), the input is digitized after that adjustment, and the power level is set using open-loop gain control.
Claim 13: Adds the full cell-search chain to claim 1: obtain the PSC from the ICS processing, use the PSC to extract the SSC from the received input, and use the PSC and SSC to extract a midamble portion from the received input (with dependent claims adding selection of the highest-energy midamble, the equation of claim 7, power-level/digitization, and VCO/NCO control).
Claim 22 (system-oriented variant): A method for adjusting frequency during ICS in a wireless network: (a) obtain a synchronization code from a received input containing a received sequence; (b) rotate the phase of the received sequence by a given frequency amount; (c) correlate a PSCH sequence with both the rotated and unrotated phases of the received sequence; (d) integrate the two correlations — with the AFC start-up method performed in parallel with step (a); and repeat (b)–(d) every N frames (N ≥ 1) for PSC/PSCH processing for SCH-location determination during ICS.
Notes on Sources and Uncertainty
- USPTO/Google Patents confirmation: The bibliographic data above is confirmed by the Google Patents record for US7236547B2 (fetched 2026-08-27), which also lists the full family (US7187732, US7412013, US8149963, US8385482, US20130142292) and the EP counterpart EP1540912B1.
- CAFC 2026 docket: Searches of CAFC 2026 dockets for "7236547" returned no results. I found no indication of any pending appeal, reexamination, or litigation involving this patent at the Federal Circuit in 2026. Given the patent lapsed in 2019 for non-payment of maintenance fees, post-expiry Federal Circuit activity is unlikely, but I cannot rule it out with certainty.
- The "chip-slip" and integration-limit tables (Tables 1–2) and PI-filter coefficient table (Table 3) referenced in the specification are part of the disclosure but are not claim limitations except as incorporated through the equation in claims 7 and 17.
Generated 8/27/2026, 2:01:58 AM
Cases on file (0)
Specific litigation cases in our database that name US patent 7236547. The free-form analysis below may also discuss cases beyond this list.
No cases on file mention this patent. Upload a CSV or add a case manually in Admin → Manage litigation cases.
Litigation summary
Past and pending lawsuits — plaintiffs, defendants, jurisdictions, outcomes, and notable rulings.
Proceedings on file (0)
All PTAB activity →AIA trial proceedings (IPR / PGR / CBM) filed at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board against this patent. Sourced from the USPTO Open Data Portal and refreshed every six hours; each proceeding number deep-links to the PTAB E2E docket.
No PTAB proceedings on file. This patent has not been challenged via IPR, PGR, or CBM. The absence is itself a signal — well-asserted patents eventually attract IPRs. The LLM analysis below may surface filings the ODP feed hasn’t indexed yet.
PTAB challenges
AIA trial proceedings at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board — IPR, PGR, and CBM. Petitioners, judge panels, claim-level invalidation outcomes from Final Written Decisions, and Federal Circuit appeals. The single most important defensive datapoint after litigation history.
Assignment history
Inventors, original assignee, and the chain of ownership recorded with the USPTO — including the correspondent attorney who recorded each assignment, since shell-LLC chains often share one repeat-player attorney even when the entity names look unrelated. Surfaces NPE / patent-troll patterns: shell-entity transfers, known asserters in the chain, repeat correspondent fingerprints, pre-litigation assignments, and bankruptcy fire-sales.
Prior art
Earlier patents, publications, and products that may anticipate or render the claims unpatentable.
Obviousness
Combinations of prior art that suggest the claimed invention would have been obvious under 35 U.S.C. § 103.
Extensions
Patent term adjustments, term extensions, continuations, divisionals, family members, and expiration dates.
Derivative works
Defensive disclosure: derivative variations of each claim designed to render future incremental improvements obvious or non-novel.
Keep exploring
Other patents in Wireless Technologies
- US 7092358I'll search for this specific patent number to verify and check for any litigation dockets. Let me run a couple more targeted searches to confirm there's no litigation and to cross-check the bibliographic data. US Patent 7,092,358 —…
- US 8032109I'll run targeted searches for this exact patent number across patent and litigation sources. Let me run one more targeted check for any litigation or appellate activity tied to this patent. US Patent 8,032,109 — Summary Important…
- US 6801579I'll search for litigation/docket information and verify details for this specific patent number. Let me check for any Federal Circuit docket activity in 2026 and USPTO records specific to this patent. US Patent 6,801,579 B1 — Analyst…
- US 6928292I'll search for authoritative information on this specific patent number and any 2026 CAFC docket activity. Let me verify whether the '292 patent appears in any 2026 Federal Circuit appeal (e.g., the Maxell v. Samsung docket) and confirm…
- US 10965512I'll search for authoritative information on this specific patent number, then synthesize. Let me check for Federal Circuit activity and the IPR outcomes specifically. Let me do one targeted check for any Federal Circuit (CAFC) 2026…
- US 8761739I'll verify the current status of this specific patent before summarizing. Let me verify the IPR outcome and the Federal Circuit matter involving this patent. US Patent 8,761,739 B1 — Analyst Summary Verification note up front: I ran…
- US 12200165I'll search for authoritative information on this specific patent number and any related litigation. Let me search for litigation and CAFC docket activity involving this patent and its assignee. Let me search for the claim text and any…
- US 12368799I'll search for authoritative information on this patent and any related litigation. Let me check the Federal Circuit docket and case details. Let me look for the actual claim text to describe the independent claims accurately. US Patent…