Litigation

Shane C. Hollmer v. Eliyahou Harari

vacated/remanded
Terminated
2012-08-24

Patents at issue (1)

Plaintiffs (1)

Defendants (1)

Summary

Federal Circuit appeal reported at 681 F.3d 1351 and decided August 24, 2012, arising from Interference No. 105,606. The court vacated and remanded the BPAI's 'reasonable examiner' standard, holding that the 'person of ordinary skill' standard applies to the §120 continuity inquiry for the intervening '838 and '768 applications.

Case overview & background

Plain-language overview of the case: parties, accused product, patents at issue, and why the suit matters.

Now let me dig into the underlying patent, the parties' identities, and the docket history.

Let me verify the ownership/assignment history and check whether any district court litigation involved the '601 patent.

Framing correction (important)

This matter is not patent infringement litigation, and treating it as such would misstate the record. Hollmer v. Harari, 681 F.3d 1351 (Fed. Cir. 2012), is the second Federal Circuit appeal in a USPTO interference — Interference No. 105,606 — between inventor parties. There is no district court, no accused product, no infringement plaintiff/defendant alignment, and no damages case. Jurisdiction rested on 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(4)(A) (appeal from the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences), not § 1338. I found no record of any infringement suit asserting the '601 patent; the dispute was resolved entirely inside the PTO and on appeal. Two other metadata points also warrant flagging: the opinion issued June 7, 2012 (the August 24, 2012 date in the case metadata is presumably the mandate/rehearing date, which I could not verify), and the formal disposition was "reversed and remanded," not vacated. See CourtListener opinion 801817.

Overview and background

The parties. Both sides are named inventors, not operating-company-vs.-NPE adversaries. Eliyahou Harari (with co-inventor Sanjay Mehrotra) prosecuted U.S. Application No. 09/310,880 (the "'880 application"), a continuation in a chain stretching back to Application No. 07/337,566 (the "'566 application"), filed April 13, 1989. Harari was a co-founder of SanDisk, and Mehrotra later became SanDisk's CEO — so the '880 side effectively represents the foundational SanDisk multi-level-cell flash patent family. Shane C. Hollmer (with co-inventor Lee E. Cleveland) owned U.S. Patent No. 5,828,601 ("Programmed Reference"), filed December 1, 1993 and issued October 27, 1998. Hollmer is a career flash-memory inventor; patent records show him later as a prolific inventor on Adesto Technologies-assigned patents (and some Monolithic Power Systems filings). Neither party is a university or a patent-assertion entity. See Foley & Lardner analysis; JD Supra summary; Lexology, "Every Application Matters".

The technology and the patents. The '601 patent claims a programmable reference scheme for sensing threshold states in multi-density (multi-level) and low-Vcc flash EEPROM arrays — programmable reference cells whose floating gates are trimmed at test time so array cells can be read against a stable reference, permitting tighter state discrimination without resistor biasing. The abstract and specification are available at US5828601. Harari's side of the interference was the '880 application and its family, directed to multi-state EEPROM read/write circuits, which incorporated by reference Application No. 07/337,579, "Multi-State EEPROM Read and Write Circuits and Techniques." The two sides were therefore claiming overlapping ground: reference/sensing circuitry for reading multiple stored levels per cell — the technical core of MLC flash. The interference turned not on claim scope but on priority: whether the '880 application could reach back to April 13, 1989, which would predate Hollmer's December 1, 1993 filing and effectively eliminate the '601 patent.

Procedural posture and why the forum mattered. The case began as a PTO interference (No. 105,606) before the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences. Hollmer moved to hold Harari's claims unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 112 ¶ 1, arguing the '579 application had been mis-identified in the '880 original disclosure and that material added by preliminary amendment was new matter under § 132; the Board agreed and entered judgment against Harari. On the first appeal, the Federal Circuit reversed, holding that at the "initial filing stage," sufficiency of an incorporation-by-reference statement is judged by whether the identity of the incorporated reference is clear to a reasonable examiner in light of the documents presented. Harari v. Hollmer, 602 F.3d 1348, 1352–53 (Fed. Cir. 2010) ("Harari I") (CourtListener). On remand the Board extended that lenient standard to the intervening '838 and '768 applications — which, unlike the '880 application, were never amended to recite the '579 serial number — found continuity intact, and entered judgment against Hollmer. In Harari II, a Prost-authored panel (Mayer and O'Malley, JJ.) reversed again: because § 120 continuity is the underlying issue, the correct vantage point is the person of ordinary skill in the art, and under that standard the "filed on the same day as the present application" language pointed ambiguously to at least two other co-pending Mehrotra/Harari applications (Ser. Nos. 07/508,273 and 07/734,221) bearing the same title. The court remanded with instructions to set the '880 application's effective filing date at December 20, 1996 — after Hollmer's 1993 filing date — which is fatal to Harari's priority position.

Why it matters. For practitioners this is a canonical § 120 priority-chain / incorporation-by-reference case: a clerical drafting artifact — failing to update serial numbers in intervening continuations — cost the '880 application over seven years of priority and, in context, the interference itself. It is now standard citation for the proposition that the Harari I "reasonable examiner" standard is a narrow exception confined to examiner review of clarifying amendments at initial filing, while continuity-of-disclosure questions are measured by ordinary skill (alongside Zenon, Cook Biotech, Advanced Display, and the companion interference decision Harari v. Lee, 656 F.3d 1331 (Fed. Cir. 2011)). See National Law Review. The commercial stakes were real even though no court ever assessed infringement: the Harari/Mehrotra family sits at the base of SanDisk's multi-level-cell flash portfolio, and the '601 patent occupies the same reference-circuitry space. Finally, the timing is notable — the decision issued June 7, 2012, roughly three months before the AIA abolished interferences (Sept. 16, 2012), making this one of the last substantive Federal Circuit interference-priority rulings of the pre-AIA era.

Sourcing caveats

  • Assignee of record for the '601 patent: not verified in the sources I could retrieve. The patent lists Hollmer and Cleveland as inventors; I could not confirm the front-page assignee, so I have not named one. Any suggestion that it was held by Programmable Microelectronics Corp. or a successor should be checked against the patent's front page before use.
  • Counsel of record for either side, and the Harari I panel composition, were not verified and are omitted rather than guessed.
  • Terminal outcome on remand — whether the '880 application issued, was abandoned, or was narrowed to a December 20, 1996 effective date — is not confirmed by the sources retrieved.
  • The August 24, 2012 termination date in the case metadata could not be matched to a specific docket event; it is later than the June 7, 2012 opinion.

Key legal developments & outcome

Major rulings, motions, claim construction, settlements, and the present posture or final disposition.

Threshold correction: this was not an infringement action

Before the chronology, one framing point that changes every item on your checklist. Shane C. Hollmer v. Eliyahou Harari was not a patent infringement litigation. It was an inter partes patent interference before the USPTO Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI) — Interference No. 105,606 — between:

  • Hollmer and Lee E. Cleveland, as inventors/owners of U.S. Patent No. 5,828,601 (the senior party, already issued), and
  • Harari and Sanjay Mehrotra, as applicants on U.S. Application No. 09/310,880 (the "'880 application"), part of a chain running back to Application No. 07/337,566 (filed 1989‑04‑13).

The "case" in your metadata is the second Federal Circuit appeal in that interference, Hollmer v. Harari, No. 2011‑1276, 681 F.3d 1351 (Fed. Cir. 2012‑06‑07), 102 U.S.P.Q.2d 1958, 2012 WL 2044627. There was never a complaint, answer, counterclaim, Markman hearing, jury, JMOL motion, or IPR — IPRs did not exist yet (AIA review proceedings became available 2012‑09‑16, after this appeal was decided), and neither party filed a 35 U.S.C. § 146 civil action; both elected direct § 141 appeal to the Federal Circuit. So the requested categories are answered below by mapping them onto the interference/appeal equivalents, and I flag where a category simply does not exist.

Two metadata flags: your prompt lists the disposition as "vacated/remanded," but the opinion's own disposition line is "REVERSED AND REMANDED." And the termination date in the metadata (2012‑08‑24) is not the decision date (2012‑06‑07); it is consistent with a later mandate/rehearing‑denial docket event, but I could not verify from a docket source in this session — treat it as unconfirmed.


Chronological developments

1. 1998 and earlier — the underlying property. Hollmer/Cleveland's '601 patent issued from work done at least by the mid‑1990s (contemporaneous Hollmer applications in the same family carry an "ATM‑" attorney docket prefix, consistent with Atmel Corporation as assignee — I did not independently verify the '601 assignment record in this session). Harari's '880 chain traces to 1989‑04‑13. The '601 patent's effective date versus the '880 application's priority date determined who won.

2. Interference No. 105,606 declared (date not verified). The interference pitted Hollmer's issued '601 patent against Harari's '880 claims.

3. Hollmer's substantive motion — § 112 ¶ 1 / new matter (BPAI, pre‑2009). This is the functional equivalent of a dispositive pre‑trial motion. Hollmer moved that Harari's involved claims were unpatentable for lack of written description because the '880 application never properly incorporated the '579 application (Harari's "Multi‑State EEPROM Read and Write Circuits and Techniques" application, filed the same day as the '566 parent in 1989) — the incorporation statement said "filed on the same day as the present application," and '579 was not filed the same day as '880. Consequently, Hollmer argued, the material Harari added by preliminary amendment was new matter under § 132. The Board granted Hollmer's motion and entered judgment against Harari, and dismissed Harari's remaining motion on the ground that it lacked standing to proceed further.

4. First appeal — Harari v. Hollmer, No. 2009‑1406, 602 F.3d 1348 (Fed. Cir. 2010‑04‑19). The Federal Circuit reversed and remanded, holding the Board applied the wrong standard and announcing a narrow rule: for an ambiguous incorporation statement being clarified by amendment "at the initial filing stage," the test is "whether the identity of the incorporated reference is clear to a reasonable examiner in light of the documents presented." The court stressed that this departed from the usual test (whether one of ordinary skill could identify the incorporated information). Full text: https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2010/04/19/Harari_v._Hollmer.pdf

5. BPAI proceedings on remand (roughly 2010–2011; exact date unverified). The Board addressed Harari's motion for benefit of the '566 filing date. It extended Harari I's "reasonable examiner" standard to the intervening '838 and '768 applications (which, unlike '880, were never amended to identify '579 by serial number and date), reasoning that "[t]he determining attribute... is the status of Harari's involved ['880 application], which has not yet issued as a patent." Applying that standard, the Board found a reasonable examiner with access to the filing papers/transmittal sheets would have understood the reference to mean '579 — so continuity held and '880 was entitled to the 1989‑04‑13 '566 date. The Board entered judgment against Hollmer (J.A. 16–17, cited at 681 F.3d at 1355–56).

6. Second appeal filed 2011‑07‑19 — No. 2011‑1276. Hollmer appealed (jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(4)). The docket shows an uncontested 28‑day extension for Appellees' brief to 2011‑08‑10 (order signed by Jan Horbaly). Counsel per the opinion:

  • For Hollmer (appellant): Deanne E. Maynard, Morrison & Foerster LLP, Washington, DC, with Alexander J. Hadjis and Kristin L. Yohannan; Gregory W. Reilly, San Diego; of counsel Martin C. Fliesler and Joseph P. O'Malley, Fliesler Meyer LLP, San Francisco.
  • For Harari (appellees): William A. Birdwell, Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, Portland, OR, with Timothy R. Volpert and Scott E. Warnick.
    (Counsel listing via FindLaw: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/summary/opinion/us-federal-circuit/2012/06/07/[259237](/patent/259237).html)

7. Decision — 2012‑06‑07, 681 F.3d 1351 (Prost, J., joined by Mayer and O'Malley). Panel reversed and remanded, with instructions to enter judgment that the '880 application's effective filing date is 1996‑12‑20 (the '708 application's filing date). Holdings:

8. 2012‑08‑24 — metadata "terminated" date. Not verified as to content. Most likely the mandate issuance or denial of rehearing (no petition for certiorari or further Federal Circuit activity surfaced in searching). Confirm against the CAFC docket for 2011‑1276 via PACER.

9. Post‑remand BPAI/PTAB action — not verified. The mandate directed entry of judgment that Harari's '880 claims get only the 1996‑12‑20 effective date. Given that Hollmer's '601 patent (issued 1998‑10‑27, though I did not verify that date in this session) stems from earlier work, the practical consequence is that Hollmer won the interference and the '601 patent emerged unimpaired. I could not locate the Board's remand decision/Paper number, any further appeal, or the '880 application's ultimate fate (issuance or abandonment) within this session — those records sit in the USPTO interference file (Interference No. 105,606) and are the key open item for a follow‑up pull.


Mapping to your checklist

Requested item What actually happened
Complaint / answer / counterclaims None. No district court action; the contest was initiated by BPAI declaration of Interference No. 105,606. No § 146 civil action was filed.
Motions to dismiss / transfer / stay pending IPR None. Functional equivalent: Hollmer's § 112 ¶ 1/new‑matter motion (granted) and Harari's priority motion (granted on remand, later reversed).
Claim construction / Markman None. No claims were construed; the dispute was priority/§ 120/incorporation by reference — pure questions of law reviewed de novo.
Discovery milestones None reportable. Interference motions practice permits limited discovery and priority depositions, but nothing in the published record signals a strategically significant discovery event.
Trial, verdict, JMOL, new trial, fees None. No jury,

Plaintiff representatives

Counsel of record for the plaintiff(s): attorneys, firms, and roles (lead counsel, of counsel, local counsel).

I'll verify the counsel listing against independent sources and fill in role/firm/experience details.

Counsel listing confirmed. Now verifying each attorney's role, firm, and background.

Threshold point on the question as framed

There is no plaintiff's counsel to identify in the sense the question assumes. This is Hollmer v. Harari, No. 2011‑1276, 681 F.3d 1351 (Fed. Cir. June 7, 2012) — the second Federal Circuit appeal in Interference No. 105,606(JL). There is no complaint, no district court docket, no PACER civil case, and no "plaintiff." As explained in the earlier sections, the alignment is appellant = Shane C. Hollmer and Lee E. Cleveland (the senior party, holders of the issued '601 patent) versus appellees = Eliyahou Harari and Sanjay Mehrotra (applicants on the '880 application). The functional equivalent of "plaintiff's counsel" is therefore Hollmer's appellate counsel, whose identities are set out in the opinion's official counsel block.

I did not find any sealed filings, pro hac vice issues, or "counsel has not yet appeared" problem — the Federal Circuit appeal was fully briefed and argued, and the counsel block is public and reproduced in multiple independent reporters.


Counsel of record for Hollmer/Cleveland (appellants)

Source of record: the counsel block appended to the opinion, reproduced at FindLaw, Hollmer v. Harari, No. 2011‑1276 and confirmed by the eLawyers opinion header (681 F.3d 1351).

Attorney Role Firm / office Note
Deanne E. Maynard Lead counsel — argued the appeal Morrison & Foerster LLP, Washington, DC (2000 Pennsylvania Ave. NW) Co-chair of MoFo's Appellate & Supreme Court practice; former Assistant to the U.S. Solicitor General (2004–2009); argued MedImmune v. Genentech (2007) and Sandoz v. Amgen (2017); 40+ Federal Circuit arguments
Alexander J. Hadjis Brief counsel (not listed as arguing) Then Morrison & Foerster LLP, Washington, DC B.S.E.E. (Ohio State); clerked for Judge Wilson Cowen, Fed. Cir. (1996–97); later co-chaired MoFo's patent litigation/IP groups, then Cadwalader, Jenner & Block (Law360 IP MVP, 2021, Roku v. Rothwell-type Waco trial), now partner at Davis Wright Tremaine, Washington, DC (joined Aug. 2024)
Kristin L. Yohannan Brief counsel Then Morrison & Foerster LLP, Washington, DC Registered patent attorney (DC bar + USPTO); contemporary MoFo work included the Apple v. Samsung litigation in N.D. Cal. (e.g., her declaration in Apple's Sony-design enforcement motion, No. 11‑cv‑01846‑LHK, Dkt. 1420‑2, July 27, 2012); later appeared under a Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft letterhead in Federal Circuit filings
Gregory W. Reilly Brief counsel, identified only as "of San Diego, CA" Affiliation not verified The opinion gives no firm, and I could not confirm whether he was in-house (the likely real party in interest was the '601 patent's assignee) or outside counsel. Do not attribute him to a firm without pulling the CAFC appearance form
Martin C. Fliesler Of counsel on the brief Fliesler Meyer LLP, San Francisco Name partner of a San Francisco IP boutique; consistent with the '601 patent's prosecution history (contemporaneous Hollmer family filings carry an "ATM‑" attorney docket prefix)
Joseph P. O'Malley Of counsel on the brief Fliesler Meyer LLP, San Francisco Same firm; no independent background detail verified in this session

Verification note on Hadjis. Two secondary directories (lawyerdb.org, LawyerDB MoFo listing) and contemporaneous MoFo caption pages from 2011–2012 (N.D. Cal. Dkt. 1184‑12; Dkt. 1091‑21) independently place Hadjis and Yohannan together at MoFo's DC office in exactly this period, corroborating the FindLaw block.


Appellees' counsel (for completeness of the appearance record)

From the same counsel block: William A. Birdwell (argued), with Timothy R. Volpert and Scott E. Warnick, all of Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, Portland, OR. Worth flagging as an odd footnote: Hadjis — Hollmer's brief counsel here — joined Davis Wright Tremaine twelve years later, in August 2024 (DWT press release).


What is not sourced, and one open item

  • No docket-sheet-level confirmation was obtained. The authoritative appearance record is the CAFC docket for No. 2011‑1276 (PACER / the court's ECF), including each attorney's appearance form. I relied on the opinion's counsel block, which is the conventional and reliable proxy, but I did not retrieve the docket itself in this session. This matters almost entirely for Gregory W. Reilly, whose firm is unstated in the opinion.
  • No Law360 or Reuters Legal coverage of this appeal was located; the trade-press coverage is the patent-blog/law-firm-alert genre (Foley, Finnegan, Lexology), none of which lists counsel beyond the opinion.
  • Real party in interest for the '601 patent remains unverified (carried over from the earlier sourcing caveats). Resolving it would also explain Reilly's role — if the assignee was Atmel Corporation (the "ATM‑" docket prefix points that way), a San Diego-based company or business-unit lawyer would fit the "of San Diego, CA" designation without a firm name.
  • Post-remand counsel (the BPAI/PTAB proceedings on the mandate) is unknown; if the file continued administratively after August 2012, different prosecution counsel may have appeared, and none of that is in the published record.

Recommended next pull: the CAFC docket sheet and appearance forms for 2011‑1276, plus the USPTO assignment record for U.S. Patent No. 5,828,601 — together these would close both the Reilly question and the real-party-in-interest gap.

Defendant representatives

Counsel of record for the defendant(s): attorneys, firms, and roles (lead counsel, of counsel, local counsel).

I'll verify the appellee/defendant-side counsel of record rather than rely on the prior summary's listing, and add role/firm/experience detail.

Confirmed the appellee-side panel listing. Now let me build out each attorney's background and check the interference-phase representation.

Bottom line first

There is no "defense side" in the infringement sense to report, and the closest true equivalent is a three-lawyer appellee team from a single firm. In Hollmer v. Harari, No. 2011‑1276, Harari (with co‑applicant Sanjay Mehrotra) was the appellee, not a defendant — and in the first appeal, Harari v. Hollmer, No. 2009‑1406, the same team appeared for the appellants. So the correct question is: who represented Harari/Mehrotra at the Federal Circuit? The answer is fully sourced from the opinions themselves, with no sealing and no separate local/in‑house counsel.

Counsel of record for Eliyahou Harari and Sanjay Mehrotra (appellees, No. 2011‑1276)

The opinion's counsel block and FindLaw's parallel listing are identical, which is a strong two‑source confirmation: "William A. Birdwell, Davis Wright Tremaine, LLP, of Portland, OR, argued for appellees. With him on the brief were Timothy R. Volpert and Scott E. Warnick." (FindLaw, Hollmer v. Harari, 2011‑1276; opinion text at 681 F.3d 1351).

Attorney Role Firm / office Patent-litigation note
William A. Birdwell Lead / arguing counsel — presented oral argument at the Federal Circuit in both Harari I and Harari II Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, Portland, OR (1300 SW Fifth Ave., Ste. 2300) Registered patent attorney with a BSEE (Oregon State) plus an IP litigation practice; argued the Federal Circuit patent appeal in Net MoneyIN, Inc. v. VeriSign, Inc., 2007‑1565 (Fed. Cir. 2008), and MSM Investments Co. v. Carolwood Corp., 00‑1092 (Fed. Cir. 2001). Also lead patent counsel for Crimson Trace in its infringement dispute with LaserMax — a representation that became the subject of Crimson Trace Corp. v. Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, 355 Or. 476 (2014), where LaserMax's inequitable‑conduct counterclaim actually named Birdwell personally as a defendant. (FindLaw Harari I — see text at 602 F.3d 1348; Net MoneyIN counsel block; Crimson Trace background)
Timothy R. Volpert Briefing counsel (on the brief in both appeals; not listed as arguing) Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, Portland, OR Portland trial/appellate partner (Willamette J.D. 1981); admissions include the Federal Circuit, Ninth Circuit, D. Or., and U.S. Supreme Court. Best known for winning Vernonia School District 47J v. Acton, 515 U.S. 646 (1995), in the Supreme Court; in 2012 he ran for the Oregon Court of Appeals. Paired with Birdwell on the Net MoneyIN v. VeriSign patent appeal. (Martindale profile; Oregonian 2012 endorsement)
Scott E. Warnick Briefing counsel (listed on the Harari II brief only; not in the Harari I counsel block) Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, Portland, OR Weakest-sourced entry. I could not locate a DWT biography or any other Federal Circuit appearance. Directory data (Martindale‑type aggregator, low confidence) lists him as an Oregon bar admittee (~2005), University of Minnesota J.D., DWT Portland, with a litigation practice. He appears to be the junior member of the team; treat his specialty as general commercial/IP litigation, unconfirmed. (Directory-side record)

Completeness and sourcing caveats

  • No PACER docket sheet was pulled. The Federal Circuit does not make its docket freely searchable without PACER, and I did not obtain a docket report for 2011‑1276 in this session. The names above come from the opinion's official counsel block (twice corroborated), not from docket appearance entries. There could in principle be additional attorneys who entered an appearance but never appeared on the brief; the opinion block is the best available proxy and is conventionally complete for briefed appeals.
  • Nothing is sealed. Interference appeals of this vintage have no sealing orders in the public record; there is no "counsel has not yet appeared" scenario — this appeal was fully briefed and argued.
  • No local counsel, no in-house counsel. The Federal Circuit has no local‑counsel rule, and both appellees are individual inventors/applicants (Harari and Mehrotra), not companies with in‑house legal departments. Harari's SanDisk affiliation did not produce separate SanDisk in-house appearance on the brief.
  • Interference-phase (BPAI) counsel is a separate question I could not verify. The attorneys who prosecuted the '880 application and litigated Interference No. 105,606 before the Board are recorded in the USPTO interference file and are plausibly overlapping with, but not necessarily identical to, the DWT appellate team. Do not assume DWT handled the Board phase; I have no source for it.
  • Firm affiliation timing. A directory-sourced résumé puts Birdwell's DWT partnership at roughly Sept. 2007 – Dec. 2011, with a return to Birdwell & Janke (Portland) after that; Super Lawyers lists him under Birdwell & Janke for 2009–2020 selections. That is a low-confidence inconsistency with the June 2012 opinion's "Davis Wright Tremaine" attribution — most likely explained by the brief being filed in 2011 and the Court simply carrying forward the caption-era firm name. Flagging rather than resolving it.
  • Later career status. A 2020s Oregon federal filing lists Volpert as Tim Volpert PC, Portland — i.e., he eventually left DWT. Also directory-sourced, but consistent across two independent hits. I did not verify any judicial appointment for Birdwell and deliberately make no such claim.

For cross-reference: opposing counsel (brief)

Since you may want the full appellate line-up — Hollmer's side was Deanne E. Maynard (Morrison & Foerster, Washington, DC, argued), with Alexander J. Hadjis and Kristin L. Yohannan, plus Gregory W. Reilly (San Diego), and of counsel Martin C. Fliesler and Joseph P. O'Malley (Fliesler Meyer LLP, San Francisco). In Harari I the Hollmer team was Fliesler (arguing) with Rex Hwang; an amicus brief came from Thomas J. D'Amico, Dickstein Shapiro (with Eric Oliver and Megan S. Woodworth). Note the naming trap: Joseph P. O'Malley of Fliesler Meyer is not Circuit Judge Kathleen O'Malley, who sat on the Harari II panel.

If the underlying need is "who do I contact about this matter today," the answer is likely nobody — the appeal terminated in 2012 and, as noted in the earlier sections, the post‑remand Board proceedings and the '880 application's fate remain unverified from the interference file.