Plaintiff

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company

5 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
5
Active
0
5 closed
Filed
2010–2011
Top venue
District Court N D Ohio Cleveland
3 cases
Also appears as a defendant in 1 case → View as defendant

Company profile

Let me research the patent litigation context.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company is the principal insurance underwriting subsidiary of The Progressive Corporation (NYSE: PGR), the Mayfield Village, Ohio–based holding company founded in 1937 and headquartered at 6300 Wilson Mills Road. Progressive Corp. reported $75.4 billion in revenue and $8.5 billion in net income for 2024 and employed roughly 70,000 people; the aggregate market value of its voting shares held by non-affiliates was about $120.9 billion at June 30, 2024 (per its 2024 Form 10-K). It is publicly traded and is not owned by a parent.

Operations. The insurer writes personal and commercial auto insurance, personal residential property insurance, and specialty lines (motorcycle, watercraft, RV), along with business general liability, commercial property, and workers' compensation. Personal auto is the core business, and the company ranked second in U.S. private passenger auto market share based on 2023 premiums written. Distribution runs directly online/by phone and through a network of more than 40,000 independent agencies. Notable technology-differentiated offerings include Snapshot, its usage-based insurance (UBI) telematics program available in every state except California, and HomeQuote Explorer, a comparison-shopping tool for property coverage.

Litigation posture. Progressive is an operating company and a net plaintiff — 5 plaintiff versus 1 defendant appearance in the tracked data. Its patents were developed internally for its own insurance business, not acquired for assertion, so it is not a patent assertion entity. The single "defendant" matter is an administrative challenge to Progressive's patents (a Liberty Mutual covered-business-method review at the PTAB), not an infringement suit filed against it. Every tracked case sits in the Northern District of Ohio (Cleveland), Progressive's home venue, rather than a plaintiff-friendly forum such as the Eastern District of Texas.

Notable cases. Between 2010 and 2012 Progressive sued competing insurers — Safeco/Liberty Mutual (No. 1:10-cv-01370, filed 2010), Allstate (2011), Hartford and State Farm (2012) — asserting its own UBI and online policy-servicing patents (the '970, '598, '358, '088, and '269 patents). Allstate settled in October 2011, taking a license; Progressive announced a UBI intellectual-property licensing program in December 2012. Liberty Mutual countered with CBM petitions (CBM2012-00002/-00004, CBM2013-00002/-00004), and the PTAB cancelled the challenged claims as obvious; the resulting Federal Circuit appeal appears in the tracked data.

Keep this research.

Save to your free workspace, then choose whether to receive updates.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company v. Allstate Insurance Company et al.

dismissed with prejudice
Docket:
1:11-cv-00082
Filed:
2011-01-12
Terminated:
2015-10-13
Patents:6064970

Progressive sued Allstate and related defendants for infringement of U.S. 6,064,970. After contested stay motions, the case was terminated by a joint stipulation of dismissal with prejudice approved on October 13, 2015.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company v. Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois et al.

stayed
Docket:
1:10-cv-01370
Filed:
2010-06-18
Patents:6064970

Progressive sued Safeco and related defendants for infringement of U.S. 6,064,970. The court denied defendants' motion to dismiss as premature and later stayed the case pending ex parte reexamination and CBM review.

Untitled case

stayed, consolidated
Docket:
1:12-cv-01068
Patents:6064970

One of two 2012 N.D. Ohio infringement cases filed by Progressive asserting U.S. 6,064,970. The case was subject to stay motions pending CBM review and was consolidated with other N.D. Ohio cases for Local Patent Rule 3.5/3.6 invalidity and unenforceability contentions; defendant mapping was not confirmed in the narrative.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company v. Hartford Fire Insurance Company

stayed, consolidated
Docket:
1:12-cv-01070
Patents:6064970

One of two 2012 N.D. Ohio infringement cases filed by Progressive asserting U.S. 6,064,970, captioned against Hartford Fire Insurance Company et al. The case was subject to stay motions pending CBM review and was consolidated with other N.D. Ohio cases for invalidity and unenforceability contentions.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company

affirmed
Docket:
2014-1466; 2014-1656 (consolidated)
Terminated:
2015-08-24
Patents:6064970

Consolidated appeals from CBM2012-00002 and CBM2012-00004 concerning U.S. 6,064,970. The Federal Circuit affirmed the PTAB's invalidity findings on August 24, 2015, rejecting Progressive's estoppel and APA arguments and finding certain claims lacked adequate written description support.