Defendant

Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company

1 case as defendant.

Cases
1
Active
0
1 closed
Filed
2011
Top venue
District Court N D Ohio Cleveland
1 case

Company profile

Let me verify a few more details on size and ownership structure.

Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company (LMFIC) is a U.S. property and casualty insurer and a subsidiary within the Liberty Mutual group. It was incorporated on October 31, 1908, under Massachusetts law as the United Druggists Mutual Fire Insurance Company; it adopted its present name on December 15, 1949, and redomiciled to Wisconsin effective December 22, 2005. Its statutory home office is 2000 Westwood Drive, Wausau, Wisconsin, with main administrative offices at 175 Berkeley Street, Boston. Ultimate parent is Liberty Mutual Holding Company Inc. (LMHC), the Boston-based mutual holding company incorporated in 2001; policyholders of LMFIC and affiliated mutuals hold membership and equity rights in LMHC. The group is not publicly traded. LMHC reported roughly $50.2–50.5 billion in 2024 consolidated revenue and employs over 45,000 people, ranking among the largest global P&C insurers.

LMFIC is a licensed operating carrier, not a patent holding entity — it is licensed in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico, with homeowners multiple peril and personal automobile liability its largest lines by direct premiums written. It participates in the Liberty Mutual intercompany pool (an 8% net participation as of 2018). Group offerings more broadly include personal auto, homeowners, commercial lines, general liability, workers' compensation, surety, group life and disability, specialty lines, and reinsurance.

Litigation posture: an operating company defending a competitor suit, consistent with the tracked data showing 1 case as defendant and 0 as plaintiff. The sole tracked matter is Progressive Casualty Insurance Company v. Allstate Insurance Company et al. (N.D. Ohio, No. 1:11-cv-00082, filed January 12, 2011), in which Progressive asserted patents covering online insurance policy service and vehicle-monitoring insurance rating against Liberty Mutual and Allstate. Notably, the plaintiff here is an operating insurer enforcing its own patents, not an NPE, and the venue was N.D. Ohio — Progressive's home district, not a plaintiff-friendly patent venue such as the Eastern District of Texas.

Liberty Mutual moved successfully to stay the claims against it pending USPTO ex parte reexamination and covered business method review of the asserted patents (the court closed the case in August 2011 and reopened it in July 2012); LMIC and LMFIC also pursued CBM petitions and Federal Circuit appeals. A related Progressive action against Liberty Mutual and others, N.D. Ohio No. 1:10-cv-1370, appears in the same court record.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company v. Allstate Insurance Company et al.

dismissed with prejudice
Docket:
1:11-cv-00082
Filed:
2011-01-12
Terminated:
2015-10-13
Patents:6064970

Progressive sued Allstate and related defendants for infringement of U.S. 6,064,970. After contested stay motions, the case was terminated by a joint stipulation of dismissal with prejudice approved on October 13, 2015.