Plaintiff

Prism Technologies LLC

9 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
9
Active
0
9 closed
Filed
2008–2012
Top venue
D. Nebraska
7 cases

Company profile

Prism Technologies LLC is a patent-holding company headquartered in Omaha, Nebraska (2323 South 171st Street, Suite 106). It was formed in 2003 as the successor to Prism Resources, Inc., an operating company active from roughly 1991 to 2001 that worked on Internet authentication and security technology. Prism Technologies, LLC was acquired by Internet Patents Corporation (NASDAQ: PTNT) in March 2015 in a deal valued at roughly $75–82 million; the parent renamed itself Prism Technologies Group, Inc. and began trading as NASDAQ: PRZM in September 2015. Gregory J. Duman was Prism's president (2011–2015). The combined company reported about nine to eleven employees at the time of the acquisition. Current corporate status and ownership could not be verified from public sources.

Operations. Prism Technologies has no product or service operations of its own; it is a licensing and enforcement vehicle. Its portfolio (over 50 issued patents as of 2015, per parent filings) covers authentication and controlled access to computer resources over untrusted networks, plus image recognition/website authentication, multi-screen display, encrypted cookies, authentication tokens, and synthetic biomaterial compounds. The assets were organized into operating subsidiaries including Secure Axcess, LLC and Millenium Biologix, LLC. The asserted patents are primarily U.S. Patent Nos. 6,516,416; 7,290,288; 8,127,345; and 8,387,155.

Litigation posture. The case data show 9 tracked matters, all as plaintiff and none as defendant — the profile of a non-practicing entity asserting an acquired/developed portfolio. Filing venue is its home district, the District of Nebraska, not a plaintiff-friendly out-of-state forum like the Eastern District of Texas.

Notable matters. Prism sued VeriSign and others in Delaware (2005), Research In Motion and Microsoft (2008), McAfee, Symantec, Trend Micro and Adobe (2010), and all five major U.S. carriers (AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile, U.S. Cellular, Verizon) in April 2012. It won a $30 million jury verdict against Sprint in June 2015. However, the Federal Circuit held the asserted claims ineligible under § 101 in Prism Technologies v. T-Mobile (2017); that ruling was subsequently applied to vacate the Sprint judgment, a result affirmed in Prism Technologies LLC v. Sprint Spectrum L.P. (Fed. Cir. 2019).

Keep this research.

Save to your free workspace, then choose whether to receive updates.

Filing activity

2008: 1 case'08'092010: 1 case'10'112012: 3 cases3'12
Cases filed per year with Prism Technologies LLC as plaintiff.

Prism Technologies LLC v. Sprint Spectrum L.P. d/b/a Sprint PCS

judgment; reversed on § 101; cert denied
Docket:
8:12-cv-00123-LES-TDT
Filed:
2012-04-04

Prism withdrew the '288 claims in March 2014. A June 2015 jury verdict found infringement of the '345 and '155 patents and awarded $30 million; the Federal Circuit affirmed, but later reversed on § 101, and the Supreme Court denied certiorari on 2019-06-10.

Prism Technologies LLC v. United States Cellular Corporation d/b/a U.S. Cellular

dismissed with prejudice
Docket:
8:12-cv-00125
Filed:
2012-04-04
Terminated:
2019-07-18

Prism sued U.S. Cellular for patent infringement, and the case was amended to add the '155 patent. The case was stayed pending the Sprint and T-Mobile appeals, then dismissed with prejudice on July 18, 2019, with each party to bear its own costs.

Prism Technologies LLC v. Adobe Systems Inc. et al.

judgment (non-infringement)
Docket:
8:10-cv-00220-LES-TDT
Filed:
2010-06-08
Terminated:
2012-12-10
Patents:7290288

Prism asserted the '288 patent only. After two Markman rounds, the court entered final judgment on 2012-12-10 granting summary judgment of non-infringement for McAfee, Symantec, and Trend Micro; Mathworks was dismissed with prejudice, and invalidity counterclaims were dismissed.

Prism Technologies LLC v. T-Mobile USA, Inc.

judgment; claims held ineligible
Docket:
8:12-cv-00124-LES-TDT

Prism withdrew the '288 claims in March 2014. The jury found non-infringement of the asserted '345 and '155 claims; post-trial motions were denied in 2016. The Federal Circuit reversed the district court's § 101 eligibility ruling and held the claims ineligible, and Prism's appeal was dismissed as moot.

Prism Technologies LLC v. Sprint Spectrum L.P.

affirmed; rehearing denied; later affirmed vacatur

Federal Circuit appeal from the Sprint district court case. The court affirmed denial of Sprint's post-trial motions (rehearing denied May 8, 2017), and later affirmed the district court's application of collateral estoppel to vacate the $30M Sprint judgment, 757 F. App'x 980 (Fed. Cir. 2019).