Plaintiff

Fenner Investments, Ltd.

2 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
2
Active
0
2 closed
Filed
2005–2011
Top venue
E.D. Texas Tyler
2 cases

Company profile

Fenner Investments, Ltd. is a Texas limited partnership with a principal place of business at 600 Goodwin Dr., Richardson, Texas, per its own complaints. Texas Secretary of State records show it was formed on September 21, 2000 (D&B lists 2001), with registered agent Peter R. Fenner, an inventor-attorney who is named as inventor on several of its patents. It is privately held, effectively family-controlled, and associated with another entity, Lightbus Technology, Inc. Business-directory data (D&B) estimates roughly one employee and annual revenue near $68,000; no audited financials are public, so size figures should be treated as estimates.

Fenner has no operating business: it does not manufacture or sell products, and its own filings describe it as holding patent rights. It is best characterized as a patent-holding/assertion entity (non-practicing entity) that acquired patents from large technology companies and asserted them against industry defendants. Its portfolio spans several technology areas: PCS/mobile-user communications-network management (U.S. 5,561,706; 6,819,670; 6,299,763 family), packet routing/switching and source-address filtering (U.S. 5,842,224; 7,145,906), and an analog joystick port interface (U.S. 6,297,751, acquired from Lucent Technologies in April 2006).

Consistent with the case data, Fenner appears only as a plaintiff (2 tracked cases, 0 as defendant), fitting the classic NPE profile. Both tracked suits were filed in the plaintiff-friendly U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Tyler Division, and other documented Fenner suits were filed in the same venue. It does not appear as a two-way litigant.

Notable tracked matters are Fenner Investments, Ltd. v. Juniper Networks, Inc. et al. (filed Jan. 6, 2005), a multi-defendant communications-network case naming Juniper, Nokia, Nortel, Lucent, Cisco, Alcatel and Ericsson, and Fenner Investments, Ltd. v. Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless et al. (filed July 6, 2011) over the '706 patent. In the Verizon case the district court found no infringement of claim 1; the Federal Circuit affirmed in February 2015. Public reporting also documents suits against Microsoft, Nintendo, Sony and 3Com/network-equipment vendors, several ending in dismissal or summary judgment against Fenner.

Watchlist

Get alerted when Fenner Investments, Ltd. sues again.

Email-only, free, anonymous. We'll notify you when Fenner Investments, Ltd. files another patent-infringement lawsuit. One-click unsubscribe from any alert.

Fenner Investments, Ltd. v. Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless et al.

final judgment of non-infringement; appealed
Docket:
6:11-cv-00348
Filed:
2011-07-06
Terminated:
2013-08-09
Patents:5561706

Fenner asserted Claim 1 of the '706 patent. MetroPCS entities settled and were voluntarily dismissed; the court adopted Verizon's construction of 'personal identification number' and entered final judgment of non-infringement on August 9, 2013. Fenner appealed.

Fenner Investments, Ltd. v. Juniper Networks, Inc. et al.

resolved by dismissals/settlements
Docket:
2:05-cv-00005
Filed:
2005-01-06

First suit asserting the '706 patent; asserted U.S. Patent Nos. 5,561,706 and 6,819,670. It produced the original Markman construction of the '706 terms. Resolved piecemeal through dismissals and settlements, including Nortel's stipulated dismissal and dismissal of certain Lucent claims.