Athena Security, LLP v. Dell Technologies, Inc.
active and ongoing- Docket:
- 7:26-cv-00025
- Filed:
- 2026-01-23
This case is active and ongoing.
Defendant
7 cases as defendant.
Company Overview
Dell Technologies Inc. is a publicly traded American multinational technology corporation headquartered in Round Rock, Texas. Founded by Michael Dell in 1984 as PC's Limited, the current company was formed through the 2016 merger of the original Dell Inc. and EMC Corporation. Dell is listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol DELL. As a major technology company, it employs approximately 120,000 people and reported revenue of $88.4 billion for its 2024 fiscal year.
Products and Services
Dell is an operating company that manufactures and sells a wide range of technology products and services. Its operations are divided into two primary segments: the Client Solutions Group (CSG) and the Infrastructure Solutions Group (ISG). The CSG division produces personal computers (desktops, notebooks, and tablets), as well as peripherals like monitors and printers, under the Dell brand. The ISG division focuses on enterprise products, including servers, data storage, and networking equipment. Dell also offers IT consulting, cybersecurity, and cloud computing services, including its "as-a-service" portfolio, Dell Apex.
Patent-Litigation Posture
Based on the provided data, Dell Technologies is an operating company that is exclusively a defendant in patent litigation. It has been sued five times and has not initiated any patent lawsuits. The cases are all located in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, a popular venue for patent litigation. The plaintiffs in these cases—Speednic LLC, Athena Security, LLP, Gaea LLC, Greenthread, LLC, and Atlas Global Technologies LLC—appear to be primarily focused on patent assertion. Several of these entities are identified by industry trackers as non-practicing entities (NPEs).
Notable Cases and Context
Dell's status as a major technology manufacturer makes it a frequent target for patent assertion entities. The plaintiffs in the tracked cases assert patents related to various technologies incorporated into Dell's products.
This case is active and ongoing.
A petition for Inter Partes Review (IPR2025-01288) was filed by Dell Technologies, Inc. and Dell, Inc. challenging US patent 9651320, but it was not instituted by the PTAB on procedural grounds.
Atlas Global Technologies, LLC sued Dell Technologies, Inc. and Dell Inc. alleging infringement of US patent 9628310. The case was dismissed with prejudice following a negotiated settlement between the parties.
This Inter Partes Review (IPR) proceeding was filed by Dell Technologies, Inc. and Dell, Inc. against patent owner Greenthread LLC challenging US patent 10734481, and it concluded in a settlement.
This Inter Partes Review (IPR) proceeding was filed by Sony Group Corporation and other entities against patent owner Greenthread LLC challenging US patent 10734481, and it concluded in a settlement.
Part of a broader assertion campaign by Atlas Global Technologies LLC, this case is an active litigation against Dell Technologies, Inc. for infringement of U.S. Patent 10,020,919.
3D Surfaces LLC sued Dell Technologies, Inc. and Intel Corporation in the Western District of Texas for patent infringement. The District Court entered final judgment for Dell after a Federal Circuit mandate invalidated claims of US 7,245,299 and US RE42,543. Appeals are ongoing following subsequent filings in 2024.