Invalidity dossier
US 4380154
Clean coal power system
Current assignee: Aavid Thermacore Inc
Added 9/26/2026, 5:58:07 PM
Active provider: DeepSeek · deepseek-v4-flash
Auto-generating section 1 of 7: Litigation summary…
Each section takes ~30-60s with web-search grounding. Keep this tab open — sections will fill in below as they complete.
Patent summary
Title, assignee, inventors, filing/issue dates, abstract, and a plain-language overview of the claims.
I'll search for authoritative information on US 4380154, including any 2026 CAFC activity.
Let me run targeted searches for litigation/docket activity and an alternate identifier check.
US Patent 4,380,154 — "Clean Coal Power System"
Search scope note: I searched Google Patents (full authoritative text), OSTI/DOE, FreePatentsOnline, Justia, and open-web sources for CAFC/PTAB/2026 docket activity tied to this number. I found no 2026 (or any) CAFC docket, PTAB/IPR, or reexamination proceeding involving US 4,380,154. There is no litigation history I can verify for this patent. Treat the "no litigation found" statement as a negative search result, not proof of non-existence.
Bibliographic data
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Patent number | US 4,380,154 A |
| Title | Clean coal power system |
| Application no. | US 06/276,655 |
| Filing date | 1981-06-23 |
| Issue/publication date | 1983-04-19 |
| Inventor | George Y. Eastman (sole named inventor) |
| Original assignee | Thermacore, Inc. (assignment recorded 1981-06-23; effective 1981-06-18, assignor George Y. Eastman) |
| Current assignee (per Google Patents) | Aavid Thermacore Inc |
| Status | Expired – Fee Related. Lapsed 1991-04-21 for failure to pay maintenance fees; fee-lapse event recorded 1991-07-02 |
| Classifications | F02C 1/04, F02C 1/10 (indirectly heated / closed-cycle gas turbine); F28D 13/00 (fluidized-bed heat exchange); F28D 15/02, F28D 15/0275 (heat pipes) |
| Research-report listing | OSTI ID 6218322 (DOE), assignee Thermacore Inc., patent file date 23 Jun 1981 |
| Cited by applicant/examiner (selected) | US 3,871,172 (Villiers-Fisher et al.); US 4,082,575 (Thermacore/Eastman); US 3,914,168; US 4,228,659; US 4,326,373; etc. |
| Later related patent | US 4,478,275 "Abrasion resistant heat pipe" (Thermacore), which expressly cites and builds on US 4,380,154 |
Source: https://patents.google.com/patent/US4380154/en ; https://www.osti.gov/biblio/6218322
Abstract (as issued)
A coal-burning power plant producing electricity at high efficiency with very low atmospheric contamination. A fluidized bed of limestone and coal burns the coal with little air pollution, and a large quantity of specially constructed heat pipes transfer heat to a closed-cycle gas turbine with very low temperature loss. Preferred heat pipes have steel casings, a thin aluminum oxide layer to prevent hydrogen permeation into the casing, and a plasma-sprayed ceramic coating on the portion within the fluidized bed to prevent erosion of the casing by solid particles in the bed.
Claim structure
The patent has 13 claims with exactly one independent claim — claim 1. Claims 2–5, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 depend from claim 1; claims 6–8 depend from claim 1 (with 7 and 8 depending from 6).
Independent claim 1 (plain language)
An apparatus for producing mechanical power, combining four elements:
- A fluidized-bed combustor into which air, coal and limestone are introduced, where the coal burns to create heat and the limestone chemically combines with sulfur in the coal to form solid compounds;
- Solids-removal means attached to the combustor to remove those sulfur-bearing solid compounds;
- A closed-cycle gas turbine that uses hot gas supplied to its input to create mechanical energy; and
- A heat exchanger whose first part connects to the fluidized-bed combustor and whose second part attaches to the gas turbine input, heating the turbine gas before it enters the turbine — the exchanger comprising multiple heat pipes with casings carrying (a) a continuous, impermeable oxide layer approximately one micron thick, and (b) a second ceramic coating between 0.010 and 0.125 inch thick covering at least the portion of the heat pipes immersed in the fluidized bed.
The protective dual coating on the heat pipes is the core structural limitation distinguishing claim 1.
Dependent claims (plain-language gist)
- 2 — The heat-pipe casings are steel.
- 3 — The impermeable oxide layer is selected from aluminum, silicon and titanium oxides.
- 4 — The second ceramic coating is selected from oxides of aluminum, silicon, titanium, magnesium and calcium.
- 5 — More than one thousand individual heat pipes are used (the redundancy/non-catastrophic-failure rationale).
- 6 — Combustor and heat exchanger are built as a single vessel with a gas-tight barrier wall separating the turbine input from the combustor, with the heat pipes penetrating that wall.
- 7 — The heat pipes are individually removable/replaceable, being bonded to gas-tight attachment means removably attached to the barrier wall (bolt-on flanges).
- 8 — The vessel is configured so the second (turbine-gas) part of the heat exchanger sits vertically above the fluidized-bed combustor.
- 9 — The second part of the exchanger comprises heat-exchange fins on the heat-output ends of the heat pipes inside a turbine-gas chamber.
- 10 — Alternative architecture: the second part of the exchanger is piping mounted internal to the heat pipes, through which the turbine gas flows (the FIG. 4 manifold embodiment).
- 11 — Adds a precipitator to remove solids from combustion gases.
- 12 — Adds means to extract usable heat from exhaust gases (e.g., boiler 26 for auxiliary vapor).
- 13 — Adds an electrical generator mechanically coupled to the gas turbine.
Points of uncertainty / caution
- Inventorship discrepancy: A scraped Justia assignee listing appears to pair this patent's abstract with "Filed: September 28, 1981 / Date of Patent: October 11, 1983 / Inventors: George Y. Eastman, Donald M. Ernst, Warren E. Thomas." That pairing is inconsistent with the authoritative record (filed 1981-06-23; issued 1983-04-19; sole inventor Eastman) and appears to be a scraper artifact interleaving entries for a different Thermacore patent. I rely on the full-text record: sole inventor George Y. Eastman.
- Term/expiry: Google Patents shows an "anticipated expiration" of 2001-06-23, but the legal-events record shows the patent lapsed 1991-04-21 for non-payment of maintenance fees. The enforceable term therefore ended in 1991, not 2001.
- No verified 2026 CAFC/PTAB activity could be located for this number; other hits for the string "4380154" belong to unrelated registrations (e.g., a Japanese patent JP4380154B2 for soil solidification, an FCC license ID, a trademark registration number), which should not be conflated with US 4,380,154.
Generated 9/26/2026, 6:49:08 PM
Cases on file (0)
Specific litigation cases in our database that name US patent 4380154. The free-form analysis below may also discuss cases beyond this list.
No cases on file mention this patent. Upload a CSV or add a case manually in Admin → Manage litigation cases.
Litigation summary
Past and pending lawsuits — plaintiffs, defendants, jurisdictions, outcomes, and notable rulings.
Proceedings on file (0)
All PTAB activity →AIA trial proceedings (IPR / PGR / CBM) filed at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board against this patent. Sourced from the USPTO Open Data Portal and refreshed every six hours; each proceeding number deep-links to the PTAB E2E docket.
No PTAB proceedings on file. This patent has not been challenged via IPR, PGR, or CBM. The absence is itself a signal — well-asserted patents eventually attract IPRs. The LLM analysis below may surface filings the ODP feed hasn’t indexed yet.
PTAB challenges
AIA trial proceedings at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board — IPR, PGR, and CBM. Petitioners, judge panels, claim-level invalidation outcomes from Final Written Decisions, and Federal Circuit appeals. The single most important defensive datapoint after litigation history.
Assignment history
Inventors, original assignee, and the chain of ownership recorded with the USPTO — including the correspondent attorney who recorded each assignment, since shell-LLC chains often share one repeat-player attorney even when the entity names look unrelated. Surfaces NPE / patent-troll patterns: shell-entity transfers, known asserters in the chain, repeat correspondent fingerprints, pre-litigation assignments, and bankruptcy fire-sales.
Prior art
Earlier patents, publications, and products that may anticipate or render the claims unpatentable.
Obviousness
Combinations of prior art that suggest the claimed invention would have been obvious under 35 U.S.C. § 103.
Extensions
Patent term adjustments, term extensions, continuations, divisionals, family members, and expiration dates.
Derivative works
Defensive disclosure: derivative variations of each claim designed to render future incremental improvements obvious or non-novel.
Keep exploring
Other patents in Energy (E)
- US 10852214I'll search for this specific patent number and check for any litigation activity. Let me check specifically for any USPTO proceedings or litigation involving this patent. US Patent 10,852,214 — Summary Important scope note: I searched for…
- US 703706US 703,706 — Search Results and Patent Summary 1. Search scope and what I actually found I ran targeted searches against Google Patents (which mirrors USPTO full-text/OCR data), general web, and patent-litigation/CourtListener-indexed…
- US 7834586I'll search for authoritative information on US 7,834,586, including current USPTO status and any 2026 CAFC activity. Let me check the PTAB proceeding and any recent litigation activity involving this patent. Let me check for any appeal of…
- US 8786133I'll search for authoritative information on US 8786133 and check for any 2026 litigation activity. Let me check specifically for any CAFC (Federal Circuit) 2026 appeal activity involving this patent. US Patent 8,786,133 — Analysis Report…
- US 9331489I'll search for authoritative records on this patent, including any CAFC 2026 docket activity. Let me check specifically for Federal Circuit 2026 activity and the PTAB proceedings. Summary of US Patent No. 9,331,489 Sources used: Google…
- US 9331488I'll search for authoritative information on this patent, including litigation/docket data. Let me check for Federal Circuit (CAFC) activity and any PTAB/IPR challenges specific to this patent. Let me check for PTAB/IPR challenges and any…
- US 3723073I'll search for this specific patent number across the requested sources. Search Results Summary Search transparency: My queries against USPTO and CAFC-specific sources returned no usable hits (empty result sets), and only one confirmatory…
- US 12302769Summary of US Patent 12302769 Note on scope of search: Searches of Google Patents, PatentGuru, and Justia confirm the bibliographic record below. Separate searches for CAFC 2026 dockets or litigation referencing patent number 12302769 (or…