Plaintiff

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC

5 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
5
Active
0
5 closed
Filed
2013–2017
Top venue
E.D. Texas Tyler
2 cases

Company profile

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC is a Delaware limited liability company and a wholly owned subsidiary of Network-1 Technologies, Inc. (NYSE American: NTIP), an IP licensing/monetization firm headquartered in New York City. It was formed in May 2013 by Network-1 (then Network-1 Security Solutions) solely to acquire the patent portfolio of Mirror Worlds, LLC — a defunct software company founded by Yale computer scientist David Gelernter and Eric Freeman that sold document-stream software called Scopeware from 2001 until it closed in 2004 (Network-1 8-K/10-K filings; Network-1 press release, May 23, 2013).

Operations. The entity has no operating business, products, or employees of its own. Its sole asset is the "Mirror Worlds Patent Portfolio": nine issued U.S. patents and five pending applications covering stream-based document storage, unified search, and indexing/display/archiving of documents. The lead patent, U.S. 6,006,227 ("Document Stream Operating System"), expired in 2016; the asserted relatives expired by April 2018 (Fed. Cir. opinion, No. 22-1600). Network-1 treats it purely as a licensing/monetization portfolio.

Litigation posture. It is a pure patent-assertion subsidiary (NPE/PAE): 5 tracked cases as plaintiff, 0 as defendant. It has sued in the plaintiff-friendly Eastern District of Texas, Tyler Division, as well as SDNY, seeking reasonable royalties rather than protecting any product of its own.

Notable cases. In May 2013 — the same month as the acquisition — it sued Apple, Microsoft, HP, Lenovo, Dell, Best Buy, and Samsung in EDTX Tyler over the '227 patent; a further Dell action followed in December 2013. Its predecessor, Mirror Worlds, LLC, won a $625.5M jury verdict against Apple in 2010 (Cover Flow, Spotlight, Time Machine), which the district court vacated and the Federal Circuit affirmed in 2013. In May 2017 the subsidiary sued Facebook (now Meta) in SDNY over the '227, '538, and '439 patents, targeting News Feed and Timeline; the Federal Circuit affirmed dismissal in December 2024. The portfolio produced licenses/settlements including $25M from Apple (2016) and $4.6M from Microsoft; Network-1 reported roughly $47.15M in Mirror Worlds licensing revenue through 2019.

Keep this research.

Save to your free workspace, then choose whether to receive updates.

Filing activity

2013: 2 cases2'13'14'15'162017: 2 cases'17
Cases filed per year with Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC as plaintiff.

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC v. Facebook, Inc. et al.

affirmed on appeal
Docket:
1:17-cv-03473
Filed:
2017-05-09
Terminated:
2024-12-04

Mirror Worlds sued Facebook/Meta asserting 6,006,227, 7,865,538, and 8,255,439 over News Feed, Timeline, and Activity Log. The district court granted summary judgment of non-infringement; after a Federal Circuit reversal and remand, the district court again granted non-infringement, and the Federal Circuit affirmed on December 4, 2024.

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC v. Facebook, Inc. (renamed Meta Platforms, Inc.)

dismissed; judgment of non-infringement affirmed on appeal
Docket:
1:17-cv-03473-JGK
Filed:
2017-05-09
Terminated:
2022-03-07

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC sued Facebook, Inc. (now Meta Platforms, Inc.) in S.D.N.Y. alleging that News Feed, Timeline, and Activity Log features infringed U.S. Patents 6,006,227, 7,865,538, and 8,255,439. The district court granted summary judgment of non-infringement and dismissed on March 7, 2022; the Federal Circuit affirmed on December 4, 2024.

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC v. Dell Inc. et al.

dismissed
Docket:
6:13-cv-00941
Filed:
2013-12-10
Terminated:
2015-11-09
Patents:6006227

Severed from the earlier Mirror Worlds action, this case asserted the '227 patent against Dell, HP, Lenovo, Samsung, Microsoft, and Best Buy. It was dismissed on November 9, 2015, with Microsoft reportedly settling for $4.65 million.

Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC v. Apple Inc. et al.

settled
Docket:
6:13-cv-00419
Filed:
2013-05-23
Patents:6006227

Mirror Worlds Technologies sued Apple and other defendants; after severance, Apple settled by paying $25 million for a fully paid-up, non-exclusive license to the '227 patent, announced July 8, 2016.