Plaintiff

Consolidated Roller-Mill Co.

5 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
5
Active
0
5 closed
Filed
—
Top venue
E.D. Michigan In
1 case

Company profile

Consolidated Roller-Mill Company (also reported as Consolidated Rolling-Mill Co.) was an American patent-holding and licensing concern active in the 1880s and 1890s, built around the roller-mill patents of inventor William D. Gray. Press and engineering-history sources place Gray as an engineer with Edward P. Allis & Co. of Milwaukee, whose Reliance and Bay State works manufactured the "Gray noiseless roller mill." I could not verify the Consolidated Roller-Mill Company's own headquarters, incorporation date, employee count, revenue, or ownership from public sources; available records are court opinions, and the entity does not appear to exist today. Treat that as unverified rather than as a finding.

Products / operations. No verifiable evidence shows the company manufactured or sold milling machinery. Its documented assets are patents: Gray No. 222,895 (1879) and No. 238,677 (1881), covering vertical/horizontal roll adjustment and roll-separating devices in roller grinding mills; Gray No. 228,525 (1880), covering belt-and-countershaft roll drives; Odell reissue No. 10,139 (1882); Birkholz No. 269,623 (1882); plus Dowling hopper-feed and Marmon countershaft patents. Notably, the defendant's answer in Coombs alleged the plaintiff had never manufactured, sold, or used the patented inventions — an allegation pleaded in defense, not a court finding.

Litigation posture. Five tracked cases, all as plaintiff and none as defendant, which is the profile of a patent-assertion/licensing entity rather than an operating manufacturer under attack. Suits were filed in equity in the U.S. Circuit Courts for the Eastern District of Michigan, the Northern District of Illinois, and the Western District of Pennsylvania — Midwestern venues where competing mill builders operated, not modern plaintiff-friendly districts such as the Eastern District of Texas.

Notable cases. Consolidated Roller-Mill Co. v. Coombs, 39 F. 25 (C.C.E.D. Mich.), sustained the Gray patent; v. George T. Smith Middlings Purifier Co., 40 F. 305 (E.D. Mich. 1889), addressed comity and res judicata; v. Barnard & Leas Mfg. Co., 43 F. 527 (N.D. Ill. 1890), affirmed as The Roller Mill Patent, 156 U.S. 261 (1895), held Gray No. 238,677 void for want of novelty and No. 222,895 not infringed; v. Walker, 43 F. 575, affirmed at 138 U.S. 124 (1891), invalidated claim 1 of Gray No. 228,525. v. Richmond City Mill-Works is also tracked.

Keep this research.

Save to your free workspace, then choose whether to receive updates.

Consolidated Roller-Mill Co. v. Barnard & Leas Manufacturing Co.

dismissed
Terminated:
1890-07-14

Patent infringement suit. Asserted patents were Gray 222,895, Gray 238,677, Odell reissue 10,139, and Birkholz 269,628. Bill dismissed for want of equity; patents held anticipated/void and no infringement. US 265,927 was not named among the patents sued on.

Consolidated Roller-Mill Co. v. William A. Coombs

judgment
Patents:289518222895

Equity suit in which U.S. Patent No. 289,518 (Dowling) was held invalid for want of invention and the bill was dismissed as to the Dowling and Marmon patents. Only the Gray patent (No. 222,895), claims 2–5, was sustained; an ancillary motion to stay the injunction pending appeal (39 F. 803) was denied.

Consolidated Roller-Mill Co. v. Richmond City Mill-Works

preliminary injunction denied
Patents:289518222895

Related suit against the maker of the mill accused in Coombs, on the same four patents asserted in the Michigan case. The reported opinion addresses only the Gray patent, and the motion for preliminary injunction was denied on bond; Dowling 289,518's presence in the asserted set is not expressly confirmed in the report.

Consolidated Roller-Mill Co. v. George T. Smith Middlings Purifier Co.

preliminary injunction denied
Patents:222895

Consolidated Roller-Mill Co. sought a preliminary injunction against George T. Smith Middlings Purifier Co. on U.S. Patent 222,895. The court denied the injunction, holding the Gray patent did not cover machines lacking the claimed lever or swinging arm and rod adjustment features, and addressed a res adjudicata/comity objection from the Wisconsin case.