Defendant

Digital Broadcasting Solutions, LLC

2 cases as defendant.

Cases
2
Active
0
2 closed
Filed
2023
Top venue
PTAB
2 cases
Also appears as a plaintiff in 2 cases → View as plaintiff

Company profile

Digital Broadcasting Solutions, LLC ("DBS") is a patent-holding entity, not an operating business. Public sources do not show products, employees, or revenue. It was founded by Todd Fitzsimmons — a patent attorney and the sole named inventor on both patents it has asserted — and its correspondence address of record is P.O. Box 199, Gardena, California 90248, tied to "Fitzsimmons IP Law." No parent company or public ticker is disclosed; DISH's filings describe DBS as a "non-practicing entity" that "seeks to license a patent portfolio without itself practicing any of the claims."

Products / services. DBS has no disclosed commercial operations. Its only known assets are U.S. Patent Nos. 8,929,710 ("System and Method for Time Shifting at Least a Portion of a Program") and 9,538,122, both directed to DVR technology — specifically time-shifted playback and delaying a commercial-skipping function until after advertisements have aired. In its infringement contentions, DBS stated it does not rely on any argument that its own apparatus or products practice the asserted patents.

Litigation posture. DBS is a one-defendant, low-volume assertion entity. Per the case data it appears as plaintiff twice and as respondent/defendant twice — but the two "defendant" matters are DISH's inter partes review petitions at the PTAB (IPR2023-00976 and IPR2023-00977), not affirmative suits against it. It has asserted the same two patents against a single target, DISH.

Notable cases. In Digital Broadcasting Solutions, LLC v. DISH Network L.L.C. et al. (filed Aug. 29, 2022 in E.D. Tex., Marshall Division before Judge Gilstrap — a plaintiff-friendly venue), DBS accused DISH's Hopper DVRs and their AutoHop/Primetime Anytime features. DISH won a § 1404(a) transfer to the District of Colorado (June 2023). DISH then filed the two IPRs; the PTAB found the challenged '122 claims unpatentable as obvious (Dec. 2024). DBS carried the dispute to the Federal Circuit (No. 25-1364/25-1365; DISH cross-appeal 25-1430).

DISH Network L.L.C. v. Digital Broadcasting Solutions, LLC

final written decision; appealed
Docket:
IPR2023-00976
Filed:
2023-05-26
Terminated:
2024-12-09
Patents:8929710

Inter partes review petition by DISH against Digital Broadcasting Solutions challenging US 8,929,710. The Board instituted on December 11, 2023, and issued a final written decision on December 9, 2024, holding 38 of 39 challenged claims unpatentable as obvious. The decision was appealed to the Federal Circuit.

DISH Network L.L.C. v. Digital Broadcasting Solutions, LLC

final written decision; on appeal
Docket:
IPR2023-00977
Filed:
2023-05-26
Terminated:
2024-12-09
Patents:9538122

DISH petitioned for inter partes review of U.S. 9,538,122. The PTAB instituted the IPR on December 11, 2023, and its December 9, 2024 Final Written Decision held all challenged claims unpatentable; DBS appealed.