Patent litigation attorney

Charles M. Jones, II

2 tracked appearances — 2 plaintiff · 0 defendant.

Specialty & background

Let me look into the tracked cases and PTAB activity.

Let me verify the notable outcomes and any PTAB counsel appearances.

Correction on the case list first: the two tracked entries are two sides of the same dispute. ControlTec, LLC v. Anthony, Inc. is the D. Del. infringement action (No. 1:24-cv-00883, filed 7/26/2024, Judge Jennifer L. Hall), and Anthony, Inc. v. ControlTec, LLC is the mirrored caption used for the parallel PTAB proceedings (IPR2025-00559, IPR2025-00636). Jones is on ControlTec's side in both — the patent owner/plaintiff — which is consistent with the 2-0 plaintiff-side tally. Both appearances are pro hac vice, i.e., he is Texas counsel appearing out of state, not local counsel.

Specialty / focus. Jones is a Dallas-based trial lawyer in Haynes Boone's Litigation and Intellectual Property groups, with a patent practice that sits inside a broad IP and commercial litigation book rather than a narrow technical niche. His firm biography describes work in high-tech, electric energy, oil and gas, heavy equipment, information technology, retail and life sciences, and lists patent matters involving WAN networking (a trial win that included a patent invalidity finding), industrial cooling equipment, smart-meter technology, mobile banking software, laser technology, retailer patent suits, and Hatch-Waxman/ANDA litigation over compounds for benign prostatic hyperplasia. His own tracked matter is electromechanical: U.S. Patent Nos. 7,207,181 and 7,421,847, both titled "Refrigeration Unit Condensation Prevention" and directed to frame/door heating in refrigerated display cases, asserted against Anthony, Inc. and Hill Phoenix, Inc. (Dover Corporation subsidiaries). The only identifiable PTAB proceedings (IPR2025-00559 and IPR2025-00636) were filed by Anthony against ControlTec and were instituted in August and September 2025 after the Acting Director declined discretionary denial over the patents' expiration.

Side preference. Contrary to what the 2/2 plaintiff-side count might suggest, this is not an NPE/PAE enforcement practice. Haynes Boone's own description states he "represents both plaintiffs and defendants in patent and trademark infringement litigation," and the results on record skew toward the defense: he was part of the Haynes Boone team that won a 2019 Marshall jury verdict for Korean client HiCon Co., Ltd. in Plastronics Socket Partners, Ltd. v. Dong Weon Hwang — no infringement despite roughly $104 million sought, with $1.36 million awarded to his clients on a royalty counterclaim (Law360 "Legal Lions"; affirmed on appeal in 2022) — and he is cited, with the same trial team, on a 2017 defense verdict for Riverbed Technology in Tyler. He also acted for patent owner PTS Diagnostics as complainant, securing a 2020 ITC final determination of infringement on cholesterol diagnostic patents. The ControlTec representation is therefore best read as enforcement for an operating company, not a standing plaintiff-side posture.

Firm context, PTAB, bar. He has been a partner at Haynes and Boone, LLP (Dallas) throughout; no prior firm history is documented in the sources reviewed. On PTAB work, the caution is that while his firm's IPR team (Ziemian, Rainey, Foster) represents ControlTec in the two instituted IPRs, and he has spoken on IPR/patent-drafting issues (Dallas Bar Association IP Section, 2015), I found no source listing him personally as IPR counsel of record — his IPR exposure appears secondary to his district court role. Bar and education: admitted in Texas in 2008; also admitted to the Fifth Circuit and the E.D., N.D., S.D. and W.D. of Texas; J.D., Texas Tech University School of Law, 2008 (summa cum laude, Order of the Coif); B.A., University of Texas at Austin, 1999. Recognized in Best Lawyers for commercial litigation and IP litigation.

Firms

Roles

  • pro hac vice2

Cases (2)