Plaintiff

Symbol Technologies, Inc.

8 cases as plaintiff.

Cases
8
Active
0
8 closed
Filed
1984–2008
Top venue
D. Nevada
1 case
Also appears as a defendant in 2 cases → View as defendant

Company profile

Symbol Technologies, Inc. was an American technology company founded in 1973 and headquartered in Holtsville, New York. The company operated as a public entity (NYSE: SBL) until it was acquired by Motorola, Inc. for approximately $3.9 billion in a deal that closed in January 2007. Subsequently, in 2014, Zebra Technologies Corporation acquired Motorola Solutions' enterprise business, which included the Symbol Technologies product lines and workforce, for $3.45 billion. The Symbol brand and technology portfolio are now part of Zebra Technologies.

As an operating company, Symbol Technologies was a leading manufacturer and supplier of mobile data capture and delivery equipment. The company specialized in products for enterprise customers across retail, transportation, and logistics industries. Its major product lines included handheld barcode scanners, rugged mobile computers, radio frequency identification (RFID) systems, and wireless local area network (WLAN) infrastructure. Symbol played a pioneering role in the development and commercialization of laser barcode scanning and mobile computing technologies.

Symbol Technologies' patent litigation history reflects its status as a technology-focused operating company. The tracked case data shows an even split, with one case as a plaintiff and one as a defendant, which is typical for a company actively developing and defending its own technology. The cases occurred prior to its acquisition by Motorola.

The company's most notable corporate context is its chain of acquisitions. The 2007 acquisition by Motorola folded Symbol's operations into Motorola's enterprise mobility division. The subsequent 2014 sale of this division to Zebra Technologies created a larger player in the enterprise asset tracking and mobility market, combining Symbol's data capture products with Zebra's specialty printing and asset tracking solutions. At the time of the Zebra acquisition, the enterprise business being acquired held approximately 4,300 U.S. and international patents.

Watchlist

Get alerted when Symbol Technologies, Inc. sues again.

Email-only, free, anonymous. We'll notify you when Symbol Technologies, Inc. files another patent-infringement lawsuit. One-click unsubscribe from any alert.

Filing activity

1984: 1 case1'841986: 1 case'871988: 1 case'90'931996: 1 case'96'99'02'052008: 1 case'08
Cases filed per year with Symbol Technologies, Inc. as plaintiff.

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. Janam Technologies LLC

settled and dismissed
Docket:
1:08-cv-00340-JJF
Filed:
2008-06-09
Terminated:
2010-12-08

Symbol Technologies, Inc. sued Janam Technologies LLC in the District of Delaware asserting US 5,334,821, US 5,835,366, and US 6,714,969 against Janam's XM-60 handheld mobile computer. The court denied Symbol's preliminary injunction motion, and the parties settled in December 2010, with Janam taking a royalty-bearing license and Motorola dismissing the litigation.

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. PSC Inc.

unknown
Filed:
1996-04-01

Symbol sued PSC concerning royalties under a March 6, 1991 license and PSC's patent-misuse defense based on Symbol's collection of royalties on the '297 and '186 patents from PSC and Telxon. The court decided cross-motions for partial summary judgment; final disposition was not verified.

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. Metrologic Instruments, Inc. et al.

partial summary judgment; final disposition unverified
Docket:
88-0461
Filed:
1988-01-26

The '186 and '297 patents were asserted against Metrologic's Series '90 hand-held laser scanners. The court's August 8, 1991 opinion addressed equitable estoppel, partial summary judgment on validity and infringement, and induced infringement under § 271(b); the final disposition was not verified in the narrative. The docket was consolidated with 88-4686 and related to 90-5053.

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. Opticon, Inc. et al.

judgment for plaintiff, affirmed on appeal
Docket:
86-8736
Filed:
1986-11-14

Symbol Technologies sued Opticon, Inc. and Opto Electronics for infringement of U.S. patents 4,387,297, 4,593,186, and 4,409,470. After a bench trial, the district court found liability for Symbol, holding the '297 and '186 patents not invalid or unenforceable and infringed, and finding that the MSH-840 device infringed claims 1-5, 27, 31, 33, 50-54 and 56-62 of the '470 patent; the MSH-850 and MSH-860 infringed only the '297 and '186 patents. The Federal Circuit affirmed at 935 F.2d 1569 (Fed. Cir. 1991).

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. Lemelson Medical, Education & Research Foundation, LP

Judgment
Docket:
2:99-cv-00397
Patents:5243655

Symbol Technologies sought a declaratory judgment that numerous Lemelson patents were invalid, unenforceable, and not infringed. The courts found the asserted Lemelson patents unenforceable due to prosecution laches, and the decision was affirmed by the Federal Circuit.

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. Metro (Suzhou) Technologies Co., Ltd. et al.

initial determination on violation issued
Docket:
337-TA-551
Patents:4387297

Section 337 investigation before the ITC brought by Symbol against Metro (Suzhou) Technologies and Metrologic Instruments. An initial determination on violation issued January 29, 2007; the narrative could not confirm whether the '297 patent was among the asserted patents.

Symbol Technologies, Inc. v. Metrologic Instruments, Inc.

settled
Docket:
2:05-cv-00509
Terminated:
2007-12-31

Symbol Technologies, Inc. accused Metrologic Instruments, Inc. of infringing U.S. Patent Nos. 5,479,002; 6,631,845; 5,646,390; 5,521,366; 5,591,952; and 6,854,655 in the Eastern District of Texas. The dispute was resolved by the December 31, 2007 global Motorola-Metrologic settlement and cross-license; no merits judgment on the '655 patent was located.