Defendant

Waqas Wahab

5 cases as defendant.

Cases
5
Active
0
5 closed
Filed
2012
Top venue
Fed. Cir.
2 cases

Company profile

Note on the entity: The name in the case data, "Waqas Wahab," is an individual person, not a company. He appears in the litigation database only as a named respondent, not as a corporate party.

Overview. Dr. Waqas Wahab is a dental professional and orthodontic technology executive based in Lahore, Pakistan. He is founder and CEO of ClearPath Orthodontics (Pvt) Ltd, which he has led since June 2007, and previously served as Director of Orthodontics at ClearCorrect (2009–2015), Director of R&D at OrthoClear (2005–2007), and Clinical Quality Manager at Align Technology (2000–2002). ClearPath is privately held; third-party business-data aggregators list it at roughly 201–500 employees, but no audited headcount or revenue figure is publicly available.

Operations. ClearPath Orthodontics manufactures clear dental aligners and provides digital treatment planning, including OEM/private-label aligner production for partners in multiple countries. Its FDA 510(k) summary (K123514) describes the "ClearPath Aligner" as a series of clear thermoformed plastic appliances for correction of dental malocclusion by continuous gentle force. The company also runs ClearPath Institute, which operates dental outreach, mobile clinics and aligner consultation programs.

Litigation posture. Wahab is a defendant in all five tracked matters and a plaintiff in none. He is not a patent-asserting entity; he was named individually in Align Technology's ITC enforcement and infringement actions against the ClearCorrect group, based on his role at ClearCorrect Pakistan (Private), Ltd. The cases are Section 337 ITC proceedings and related Federal Circuit appeals, not district-court NPE suits, so the usual plaintiff-friendly-venue analysis does not apply.

Notable cases. All tracked matters arise from Align Technology, Inc. v. ClearCorrect Operating, LLC et al. Align filed an enforcement complaint at the ITC on March 1, 2012 (Inv. No. 337-TA-562) alleging violation of a 2006 consent order entered after Align's settlement with OrthoClear, and filed a parallel infringement complaint (Inv. No. 337-TA-833). Respondents included ClearCorrect USA, ClearCorrect Pakistan, Mudassar Rathore, Waqas Wahab, Nadeem Arif and Asim Waheed. The Federal Circuit's 2014 decision in Align Technology, Inc. v. International Trade Commission, 771 F.3d 1317, reversed the Commission on the scope of the consent order and remanded. In April 2015 the parties reached a termination agreement resolving the remanded enforcement action, contingent on the outcome of the '833 appeal.

Align Technology, Inc. v. ClearCorrect Operating, LLC et al.

ITC found violation; on appeal
Filed:
2012-05-01
Patents:6685469

Align brought an ITC enforcement proceeding under 19 C.F.R. § 210.75 to enforce the 337-TA-562 Consent Order against ClearCorrect Operating, LLC, ClearCorrect Pakistan (Private), Ltd., and four individuals. The ITC found a violation of the consent order, leading to Federal Circuit appeals.

Align Technology, Inc. v. ClearCorrect Operating, LLC et al.

terminated/no violation
Docket:
337-TA-562 (Enforcement Proceeding)
Filed:
2012-03-01
Terminated:
2016-09-23
Patents:6602070

Align Technology filed an enforcement proceeding against ClearCorrect and its officers to enforce the 2006 Consent Order from Inv. No. 337-TA-562. The action was directed at the '511 and '880 patents specifically, but the Consent Order included the '070 patent. The Commission ultimately found no violation and terminated the proceeding, rescinding cease-and-desist orders.

Align Technology, Inc. v. ClearCorrect Operating, LLC et al.

resolved by termination agreement
Docket:
337-TA-562 (Enforcement)
Filed:
2012-03-01
Terminated:
2015-04-07

Align filed an enforcement proceeding under 19 C.F.R. § 210.75 alleging ClearCorrect and bound officers violated the 2006 consent order. The '880 and '511 patents were the basis for the enforcement complaint; the Commission found no violation, Align appealed, and the matter was resolved by an April 7, 2015 termination agreement.

Align Technology, Inc. v. U.S. International Trade Commission et al.

vacated and remanded
Docket:
2013-1240, 2013-1363
Terminated:
2014-07-18
Patents:6227850

Align appealed from the ITC enforcement proceeding relating to the 2006 consent order that included U.S. Patent No. 6,227,850. The Federal Circuit vacated and remanded, holding the ITC exceeded its authority in reviewing the ALJ's order denying termination and remanding for trial on whether former OrthoClear employees violated the Consent Order.

Align Technology, Inc. v. International Trade Commission et al.

reversed and remanded
Docket:
2013-1240, 2013-1363
Terminated:
2014-07-18

Appeal from the ITC's ClearCorrect enforcement proceeding. The Federal Circuit reversed and remanded on procedural grounds, holding the ITC exceeded its authority by reviewing an ALJ's order denying a motion to terminate. The narrative treats the '840 patent connection as family-level and unconfirmed; the enforcement dispute is described as involving the 2006 Consent Order and the '880 and '511 patents.