Plano Encryption Technologies, LLC v. Shutterfly, Inc.
Terminated- Docket:
- 2:16-cv-01053-JRG
- Filed:
- 2016-09-28
PET infringement action against Shutterfly, Inc. in the Eastern District of Texas, part of the campaign involving U.S. 5,974,550.
Defendant
1 case as defendant.
Shutterfly, Inc. is a privately held, Apollo Global Management–backed personalized photo products and photography company founded in 1999 and headquartered in Redwood City, California (with a corporate office later listed in San Jose). It was formerly public on NASDAQ under ticker SFLY until Apollo funds acquired it in an all-cash transaction at $51.00 per share (approximately $2.7 billion enterprise value) that closed September 25, 2019. At that time the company reported more than 10,000 employees and over $2 billion in annual revenue; PitchBook later lists roughly 11,000 employees (2024). It is controlled by funds managed by affiliates of Apollo, with Snapfish's prior owners as a minority stakeholder.
Products and operations. Shutterfly operates three divisions: Shutterfly Consumer (personalized photo books, cards, stationery, calendars, prints, gifts, wall art and home décor, sold via website and mobile apps); Lifetouch (school and portrait photography, including "Picture Day" and studio partnerships), acquired in 2018 for $825 million; and Shutterfly Business Solutions (B2B digital printing and personalized communications, including healthcare billing/statements). It manufactures products at U.S. facilities in Arizona, the Carolinas and Plano, Texas. The company acquired Snapfish (completed January 2020), Kodak Gallery (2012), Tiny Prints/Wedding Paper Divas (2011) and Spoonflower (2021). It holds a substantial patent portfolio, primarily in image processing and digital photography.
Patent-litigation posture. The tracked data show Shutterfly as a defendant in a single case and as a plaintiff in none, consistent with an operating company defending against outside assertions rather than an entity monetizing patents.
Notable case. Plano Encryption Technologies, LLC v. Shutterfly, Inc., No. 2:16-cv-01053 (E.D. Tex., filed September 28, 2016; since closed). Plaintiff Plano Encryption Technologies is a Texas LLC and wholly owned subsidiary of Koba Holdings, LLC; Stanford's NPE database classifies it as a non-practicing entity asserting acquired encryption patents (U.S. 5,974,550; 5,991,399; 5,892,899) covering tamper-resistant modules. Shutterfly was one of many targets in a campaign concentrated in the Eastern District of Texas that also named Best Buy, Etsy, Groupon, J.C. Penney, Match.com, Alkami and State Farm, along with numerous banks.
PET infringement action against Shutterfly, Inc. in the Eastern District of Texas, part of the campaign involving U.S. 5,974,550.