8 known cases. View patent page →
RAH alleged that Ricoh's Pro C651EX/C751/C901, MP C-series and other products with EFI Fiery controllers and Color Profiler Suite infringe claims 29, 30, 32, 34 and 35 of the '704 patent. The court dismissed all fourteen of Ricoh's invalidity and non-infringement counterclaims. The litigation was later referred to as resolved.
The '704 patent was named as one of seven patents-in-suit. Outcome was not confirmed in the sources retrieved, but the case is generally reported as settling.
RAH alleged that Quad/Graphics's use, manufacture, or importation of QG Accused Print Workflow Systems, including QG Print Servers with EFI Fiery print server, Command Workstation, and Color Profiler Suite, infringed the '704 patent. The case was transferred to the E.D. Wisconsin.
RAH asserted the '704 patent, which was one of six patents in the original complaint and one of eight in the amended complaint. RAH alleged Xerox had knowledge of the '704 at least from a February 26, 2015 claim-chart letter. The N.D. Illinois case was closed in September 2018, consistent with transfer/consolidation to the W.D. New York action.
EFI sought a declaratory judgment of non-infringement of the '704 patent (along with the '870, '008, '897 and '444 patents), arguing RAH's suits against EFI's customers created a real controversy. The court granted RAH's motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction and indicated it was inclined to transfer to the E.D. Virginia.
California MDL proceeding coordinating RAH patent litigation. The Dalim case was transferred and consolidated into this MDL. The '704 patent was among the asserted RAH patents in the related coordinated litigation.
The '704 patent was among the asserted RAH patents in this coordinated litigation. The case was transferred by MDL Conditional Transfer Order to the N.D. California.
The '704 patent was named as one of the patents-in-suit, along with the '870, '897, '008, '340, etc. The outcome was not confirmed in the material reviewed; filed in the same 2019 wave as the Adobe IPRs.