Patent US10514223

Litigation summary

Past and pending lawsuits — plaintiffs, defendants, jurisdictions, outcomes, and notable rulings.

Active provider: Google · gemini-2.5-pro

No PTAB proceedings on file. This patent has not been challenged through Inter Partes Review, Post-Grant Review, or Covered Business Method review at the USPTO. The absence is itself a signal — well-asserted patents eventually attract IPRs.

Cases on file (20)

Group view →

Specific litigation cases in our database that name US patent US10514223. The free-form analysis below may also discuss cases beyond this list.

Litigation summary

Past and pending lawsuits — plaintiffs, defendants, jurisdictions, outcomes, and notable rulings.

✓ Generated

Litigation History of US Patent No. 10,514,223

As of May 1, 2026, U.S. Patent No. 10,514,223 B1 is the subject of extensive litigation across multiple United States District Courts and the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The patent, assigned to ABC IP, LLC, has been asserted against numerous parties. The following is a list of known legal cases involving this patent.

Contradiction With Provided Information: The previously generated "Patent Summary" section stated, "As of early 2026, there is no public record of this patent being a subject of litigation before the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC)." This is incorrect. Public records indicate at least one case involving this patent has been filed in the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.

Here is a summary of the known litigation:

Plaintiff(s) Defendant(s) Jurisdiction Case Number Filing Date Status/Outcome
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC BIG DADDY ENTERPRISES, INC. Florida Northern District Court 1:21-cv-00149 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC BIG DADDY UNLIMITED Florida Southern District Court 1:21-cv-00149 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC, ABC IP, LLC WIDE OPEN ENTERPRISES LLC, OTTOFIREARMS LLC Ohio Northern District Court 1:22-cv-00280 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC LAWRENCE DEGARMO, TOMMY TOYS, LLC Oklahoma Northern District Court 4:22-cv-00107 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC LAWRENCE DEGARMO, TOMMY TOYS, LLC Michigan Eastern District Court 4:22-cv-00107 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC LAWRENCE DEGARMO, TOMMY TOYS, LLC Oklahoma Northern District Court 4:23-cv-00021 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC, ABC IP, LLC LAWRENCE DEGARMO, TOMMY TOYS, LLC Oklahoma Eastern District Court 4:23-cv-00021 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. ORION TACTICAL LLC, ORION ARMS LLC Wisconsin Eastern District Court 2:25-cv-00852 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. B&T USA LLC, B&T AG Arizona District Court 2:25-cv-04938 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. PEAK TACTICAL LLC Wyoming District Court 1:25-cv-00124 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. BOISE BLACK RIFLE LLC Idaho District Court 4:25-cv-00299 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC KE ARMS, LLC, SHAWN NEALON, RUSSELL PHAGAN, BROWNNELLS, INC. Arizona District Court 2:26-cv-00085 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC, ABC IP, LLC BDU, LLC Idaho District Court 1:26-cv-00001 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. POST FALLS-ISH, LLC Idaho District Court 4:26-cv-00001 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. BLACK RAIN ORDNANCE, INC. Missouri Eastern District Court 4:26-cv-00018 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC TURNER’S OUTDOORSMAN, INC., DBA TURNER’S OUTDOORSMAN Iowa Southern District Court 4:26-cv-00015 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC THE GUN STORE, INC., DBA THE GUN STORE Washington Eastern District Court 2:26-cv-00014 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. TACTICAL DEPLOYMENT SYSTEMS, LLC, DBA GUNFIGHTER Wyoming District Court 1:26-cv-00018 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC WIDE OPEN ENTERPRISES LLC, MATTHEW J. LOSTY, KEVIN D. MAXWELL Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit 26-1527 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC STRYKER ENTERPRISES, LLC, DBA 3CR TACTICAL Louisiana Eastern District Court 2:26-cv-00576 Unknown Unknown
ABC IP, LLC, RARE BREED TRIGGERS, LLC JSD SUPPLY, LLC, JSD SUPPLY INC. Illinois Northern District Court 1:26-cv-01072 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. RECOIL, LLC, DBA RECOIL GUN WORKS Texas Eastern District Court 2:26-cv-00033 Unknown Unknown
RARE BREED TRIGGERS, INC., ABC IP, INC. J.C. ARMS & AMMUNITION, LLC Texas Eastern District Court 2:26-cv-00201 Unknown Unknown

Generated 5/1/2026, 10:46:45 PM