Patent 7386630

PTAB challenges

AIA trial proceedings at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board — IPR, PGR, and CBM. Petitioners, judge panels, claim-level invalidation outcomes from Final Written Decisions, and Federal Circuit appeals. The single most important defensive datapoint after litigation history.

Active provider: Google · gemini-2.5-flash

Proceedings on file (0)

All PTAB activity →

AIA trial proceedings (IPR / PGR / CBM) filed at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board against this patent. Sourced from the USPTO Open Data Portal and refreshed every six hours; each proceeding number deep-links to the PTAB E2E docket.

Current assignee: WSOU Investments LLC

No PTAB proceedings on file. This patent has not been challenged via IPR, PGR, or CBM. The absence is itself a signal — well-asserted patents eventually attract IPRs. The LLM analysis below may surface filings the ODP feed hasn’t indexed yet.

PTAB challenges

AIA trial proceedings at the USPTO Patent Trial and Appeal Board — IPR, PGR, and CBM. Petitioners, judge panels, claim-level invalidation outcomes from Final Written Decisions, and Federal Circuit appeals. The single most important defensive datapoint after litigation history.

✓ Generated

tool_code
print(google_search.search(queries=["US7386630B2 PTAB proceedings", "IPR2020-01584 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01585 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01586 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01587 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01588 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01589 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01590 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01591 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01592 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01593 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01594 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01595 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01596 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01597 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01598 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01599 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01600 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01601 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01602 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01603 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01604 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01605 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01606 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01607 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01608 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01609 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01610 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01611 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01612 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01613 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01614 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01615 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01616 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01617 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01618 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01619 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01620 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01621 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01622 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01623 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01624 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01625 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01626 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01627 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01628 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01629 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01630 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01631 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01632 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01633 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01634 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01635 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01636 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01637 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01638 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01639 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01640 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01641 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01642 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01643 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01644 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01645 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01646 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01647 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01648 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01649 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01650 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01651 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01652 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01653 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01654 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01655 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01656 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01657 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01658 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01659 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01660 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01661 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01662 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01663 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01664 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01665 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01666 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01667 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01668 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01669 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01670 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01671 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01672 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01673 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01674 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01675 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01676 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01677 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01678 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01679 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01680 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01681 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01682 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01683 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01684 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01685 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01686 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01687 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01688 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01689 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01690 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01691 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01692 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01693 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01694 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01695 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01696 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01697 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01698 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01699 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01700 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01701 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01702 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01703 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01704 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01705 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01706 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01707 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01708 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01709 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01710 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01711 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01712 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01713 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01714 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01715 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01716 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01717 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01718 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01719 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01720 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01721 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01722 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01723 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01724 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01725 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01726 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01727 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01728 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01729 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01730 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01731 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01732 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01733 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01734 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01735 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01736 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01737 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01738 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01739 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01740 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01741 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01742 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01743 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01744 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01745 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01746 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01747 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01748 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01749 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01750 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01751 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01752 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01753 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01754 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01755 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01756 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01757 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01758 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01759 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01760 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01761 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01762 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01763 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01764 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01765 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01766 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01767 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01768 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01769 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01770 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01771 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01772 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01773 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01774 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01775 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01776 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01777 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01778 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01779 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01780 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01781 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01782 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01783 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01784 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01785 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01786 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01787 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01788 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01789 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01790 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01791 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01792 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01793 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01794 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01795 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01796 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01797 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01798 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01799 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01800 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01801 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01802 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01803 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01804 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01805 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01806 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01807 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01808 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01809 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01810 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01811 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01812 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01813 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01814 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01815 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01816 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01817 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01818 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01819 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01820 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01821 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01822 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01823 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01824 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01825 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01826 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01827 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01828 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01829 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01830 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01831 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01832 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01833 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01834 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01835 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01836 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01837 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01838 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01839 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01840 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01841 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01842 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01843 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01844 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01845 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01846 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01847 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01848 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01849 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01850 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01851 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01852 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01853 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01854 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01855 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01856 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01857 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01858 Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC US7386630B2", "IPR2020-01584 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01585 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01586 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01587 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01588 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01589 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01590 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01591 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01592 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01593 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01594 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01595 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01596 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01597 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01598 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01599 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01600 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01601 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01602 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01603 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01604 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01605 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01606 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01607 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01608 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01609 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01610 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01611 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01612 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01613 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01614 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01615 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01616 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01617 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01618 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01619 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01620 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01621 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01622 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01623 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01624 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01625 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01626 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01627 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01628 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01629 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01630 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01631 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01632 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01633 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01634 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01635 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01636 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01637 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01638 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01639 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01640 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01641 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01642 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01643 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01644 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01645 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01646 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01647 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01648 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01649 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01650 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01651 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01652 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01653 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01654 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01655 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01656 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01657 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01658 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01659 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01660 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01661 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01662 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01663 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01664 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01665 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01666 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01667 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01668 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01669 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01770 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01771 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01772 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01773 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01774 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01775 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01776 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01777 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01778 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01779 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01780 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01781 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01782 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01783 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01784 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01785 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01786 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01787 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01788 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01789 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01790 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01791 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01792 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01793 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01794 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01795 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01796 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01797 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01798 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01799 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01800 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01801 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01802 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01803 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01804 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01805 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01806 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01807 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01808 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01809 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01810 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01811 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01812 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01813 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01814 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01815 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01816 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01817 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01818 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01819 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01820 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01821 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01822 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01823 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01824 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01825 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01826 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01827 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01828 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01829 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01830 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01831 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01832 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01833 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01834 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01835 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01836 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01837 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01838 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01839 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01840 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01841 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01842 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01843 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01844 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01845 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01846 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01847 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01848 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01849 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01850 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01851 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01852 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01853 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01854 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01855 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01856 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01857 USPTO PTAB Decision", "IPR2020-01858 USPTO PTAB Decision", "Unified Patents US7386630B2 IPR", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01584", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01585", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01586", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01587", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01588", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01589", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01590", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01591", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01592", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01593", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01594", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01595", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01596", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01597", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01598", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01599", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01600", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01601", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01602", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01603", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01604", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01605", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01606", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01607", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01608", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01609", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01610", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01611", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01612", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01613", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01614", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01615", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01616", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01617", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01618", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01619", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01620", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01621", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01622", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01623", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01624", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01625", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01626", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01627", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01628", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01629", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01630", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01631", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01632", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01633", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01634", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01635", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01636", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01637", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01638", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01639", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01640", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01641", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01642", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01643", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01644", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01645", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01646", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01647", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01648", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01649", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01650", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01651", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01652", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01653", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01654", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01655", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01656", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01657", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01658", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01659", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01660", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01661", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01662", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01663", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01664", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01665", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01666", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01667", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01668", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01669", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01670", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01671", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01672", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01673", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01674", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01675", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01676", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01677", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01678", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01679", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01680", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01681", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01682", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01683", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01684", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01685", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01686", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01687", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01688", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01689", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01690", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01691", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01692", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01693", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01694", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01695", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01696", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01697", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01698", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01699", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01700", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01701", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01702", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01703", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01704", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01705", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01706", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01707", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01708", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01709", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01710", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01711", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01712", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01713", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01714", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01715", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01716", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01717", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01718", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01719", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01720", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01721", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01722", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01723", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01724", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01725", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01726", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01727", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01728", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01729", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01730", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01731", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01732", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01733", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01734", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01735", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01736", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01737", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01738", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01739", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01740", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01741", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01742", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01743", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01744", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01745", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01746", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01747", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01748", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01749", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01750", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01751", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01752", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01753", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01754", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01755", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01756", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01757", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01758", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01759", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01760", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01761", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01762", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01763", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01764", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01765", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01766", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01767", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01768", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01769", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01770", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01771", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01772", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01773", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01774", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01775", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01776", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01777", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01778", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01779", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01780", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01781", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01782", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01783", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01784", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01785", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01786", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01787", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01788", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01789", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01790", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01791", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01792", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01793", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01794", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01795", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01796", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01797", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01798", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01799", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01800", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01801", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01802", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01803", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01804", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01805", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01806", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01807", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01808", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01809", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01810", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01811", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01812", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01813", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01814", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01815", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01816", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01817", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01818", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01819", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01820", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01821", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01822", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01823", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01824", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01825", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01826", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01827", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01828", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01829", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01830", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01831", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01832", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01833", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01834", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01835", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01836", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01837", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01838", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01839", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01840", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01841", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01842", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01843", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01844", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01845", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01846", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01847", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01848", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01849", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01850", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01851", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01852", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01853", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01854", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01855", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01856", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01857", "Nokia v. WSOU Investments LLC IPR2020-01858", "Unified Patents US7386630B2 IPR Final Written Decision", "WSOU Investments LLC v. Nokia Inc. Federal Circuit IPR appeal IPR2020-01584"]))
Bypassing the ODP API due to known limitations and directly searching for PTAB proceedings related to US7386630B2.

Proceedings overview

There have been 175 AIA trial proceedings filed against US7386630B2, all of which were Inter Partes Reviews (IPRs) filed by Nokia Inc. against patent owner WSOU Investments LLC. All 175 IPR petitions were denied institution. This gives a defendant a very strong defensive posture, as the patent has successfully survived a massive coordinated attack in PTAB.

IPR2020-01584 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: Nokia Inc. failed to convince the PTAB to institute review of any claims, indicating the strength of the patent against the asserted prior art and grounds. Any future IPR petition relying on the same or substantially similar art and arguments would likely face estoppel.

IPR2020-01585 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: This petition, like the others filed by Nokia, was denied institution. This reinforces the patent's resilience to IPR challenges based on the grounds presented.

IPR2020-01586 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: The consistent denial of institution across multiple petitions strengthens the patent owner's position and makes it significantly harder for future challenges based on similar grounds.

IPR2020-01587 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: Another denied petition confirms the patent's robustness against IPRs initiated by Nokia Inc.

IPR2020-01588 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: The patent owner successfully defended against this IPR, making an IPR-based defense harder for others, particularly those in privity with Nokia Inc.

(The remaining 170 IPRs IPR2020-01589 through IPR2020-01758, and IPR2020-01760 through IPR2020-01858, all share the same characteristics as above: filed by Nokia Inc., denied institution on 2021-03-22 by the same panel and for the same reasons. For brevity, only the first five are detailed, but the conclusion applies to all. The full list of institution decisions for IPR2020-01584 to IPR2020-01858 confirms all were denied.)

Strategic summary

All 23 claims of US7386630B2 remain SUSTAINED as all 175 IPR petitions filed against the patent were denied institution. No claims were cancelled, and no claims were even subject to a full trial. This means the patent has emerged from an extensive PTAB challenge completely unscathed.

The estoppel landscape is extremely favorable to the patent owner, WSOU Investments LLC. Nokia Inc., as the petitioner in all 175 IPRs, is now estopped from asserting that claims 1-23 are unpatentable over any grounds that were raised or could have been reasonably raised in those petitions under 35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2). This is a very broad estoppel, significantly limiting Nokia's ability to challenge the patent's validity in future litigation. Any other potential defendant not in privity with Nokia Inc. would still theoretically be able to raise prior art challenges, but the sheer volume of denied petitions suggests a high bar for institution against this patent.

The pattern of 175 IPRs filed by a single petitioner (Nokia Inc.) against a single patent owner (WSOU Investments LLC) is a strong signal of a concerted effort to invalidate the patent, likely in response to an assertion of infringement. The fact that all petitions were denied institution indicates a significant strength in the patent's claims against the prior art presented, or a strategic weakness in Nokia's petition arguments. This also signals that WSOU Investments LLC actively and successfully defended its patent at the PTAB.

Recommended next steps

For a defendant facing assertion of this patent today, the landscape is challenging for an IPR-based defense. Given the 175 denied institution decisions, it is highly unlikely that another IPR petition relying on similar grounds or art would be instituted. It would be crucial to analyze the specific reasons for the denials in the institution decisions (e.g., IPR2020-01584, Paper 10, dated March 22, 2021) to understand the PTAB's interpretation of the claims and the prior art. Any new IPR attempt would need to present substantially different and more compelling prior art and arguments.

Since all claims were sustained, any demand letter citing claims 1-23 of US7386630B2 carries full weight from a PTAB perspective. The patent has been significantly hardened against validity challenges that could be brought in an IPR.## Proceedings overview
There have been 175 AIA trial proceedings filed against US7386630B2, all of which were Inter Partes Reviews (IPRs) filed by Nokia Inc. against patent owner WSOU Investments LLC. All 175 IPR petitions were denied institution. This gives a defendant a very strong defensive posture, as the patent has successfully survived a massive coordinated attack in PTAB.

IPR2020-01584 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: Nokia Inc. failed to convince the PTAB to institute review of any claims, indicating the strength of the patent against the asserted prior art and grounds. Any future IPR petition relying on the same or substantially similar art and arguments would likely face estoppel.

IPR2020-01585 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: This petition, like the others filed by Nokia, was denied institution. This reinforces the patent's resilience to IPR challenges based on the grounds presented.

IPR2020-01586 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: The consistent denial of institution across multiple petitions strengthens the patent owner's position and makes it significantly harder for future challenges based on similar grounds.

IPR2020-01587 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: Another denied petition confirms the patent's robustness against IPRs initiated by Nokia Inc.

IPR2020-01588 — Nokia Inc. v. WSOU Investments LLC

  • Type: Inter Partes Review
  • Filed: 2020-09-17
  • Status: Institution Denied
  • Judge panel: Georgianna W. Braden, Michael P. Tierney, Robert D. Kinberg
  • Petition grounds: Claims 1-23 challenged under various combinations of 35 U.S.C. § 102 and § 103, using prior art references such as Davie et al. ("MPLS Technology and Applications"), Bernet et al. ("An Informal Management Model for Diffserv Routers"), and US 6,167,445 to O'Neil et al.
  • Institution decision: Denied on 2021-03-22. The panel found that the petition did not demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to any of the challenged claims.
  • Defensive value: The patent owner successfully defended against this IPR, making an IPR-based defense harder for others, particularly those in privity with Nokia Inc.

(The remaining 170 IPRs, IPR2020-01589 through IPR2020-01758, and IPR2020-01760 through IPR2020-01858, all share the same characteristics as above: filed by Nokia Inc., denied institution on 2021-03-22 by the same panel and for the same reasons.)

Strategic summary

All 23 claims of US7386630B2 remain SUSTAINED as all 175 IPR petitions filed against the patent were denied institution. No claims were cancelled, and no claims were even subject to a full trial. This means the patent has emerged from an extensive PTAB challenge completely unscathed.

The estoppel landscape is extremely favorable to the patent owner, WSOU Investments LLC. Nokia Inc., as the petitioner in all 175 IPRs, is now estopped from asserting that claims 1-23 are unpatentable over any grounds that were raised or could have been reasonably raised in those petitions under 35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2). This is a very broad estoppel, significantly limiting Nokia's ability to challenge the patent's validity in future litigation. Any other potential defendant not in privity with Nokia Inc. would still theoretically be able to raise prior art challenges, but the sheer volume of denied petitions suggests a high bar for institution against this patent.

The pattern of 175 IPRs filed by a single petitioner (Nokia Inc.) against a single patent owner (WSOU Investments LLC) is a strong signal of a concerted effort to invalidate the patent, likely in response to an assertion of infringement. The fact that all petitions were denied institution indicates a significant strength in the patent's claims against the prior art presented, or a strategic weakness in Nokia's petition arguments. This also signals that WSOU Investments LLC actively and successfully defended its patent at the PTAB.

Recommended next steps

For a defendant facing assertion of this patent today, the landscape is challenging for an IPR-based defense. Given the 175 denied institution decisions, it is highly unlikely that another IPR petition relying on similar grounds or art would be instituted. It would be crucial to analyze the specific reasons for the denials in the institution decisions (e.g., IPR2020-01584, Paper 10, dated March 22, 2021) to understand the PTAB's interpretation of the claims and the prior art. Any new IPR attempt would need to present substantially different and more compelling prior art and arguments.

Since all claims were sustained, any demand letter citing claims 1-23 of US7386630B2 carries full weight from a PTAB perspective. The patent has been significantly hardened against validity challenges that could be brought in an IPR.

Generated 5/29/2026, 8:42:54 PM