Patent 10277728

Prior art

Earlier patents, publications, and products that may anticipate or render the claims unpatentable.

Active provider: Google · gemini-2.5-flash

Prior art

Earlier patents, publications, and products that may anticipate or render the claims unpatentable.

✓ Generated

To identify the most relevant prior art for US patent 10277728, I have analyzed the patent document itself and searched for the cited prior art. The patent US10277728 explicitly discusses several prior art references in its "BACKGROUND SECTION OF THE INVENTION" and "Definitions" sections.

The following prior art documents are discussed within US10277728:

  1. US 2013/0275899 A1
  2. US 8,364,183 B1
  3. US 8,526,973 B1
  4. US 8,359,014 B1

Below is the detailed analysis for each of these references:


1. US Patent Application Publication 2013/0275899 A1

  • Full Citation: US 2013/0275899 A1, "Limited-Distraction User Interface", published October 24, 2013.

  • Publication Date: October 24, 2013.

  • Filing Date: April 17, 2012.

  • Brief Description: This patent application proposes a limited-distraction user interface that displays fewer selectable user interface objects than a non-limited user interface when a device is determined to be operating in a limited-distraction context. It can then switch to a non-limited user interface when the device is not in such a context. The description in US10277728 notes that this prior art "relies on substantial input from the user even in the limited-distraction context, making it difficult for a user to use a mobile phone in such context."

  • Potential Anticipation (35 U.S.C. § 102):
    US 2013/0275899 A1 potentially anticipates claims in US10277728 related to adapting a user interface based on a user's activity or context. However, US10277728 distinguishes itself by emphasizing the "without any input by a user" aspect for determining message arrival and informing the user, and specifically by automatically "reading aloud" the message body if no affirmative action is taken to stop it, or only reading aloud if an affirmative action is taken to command it. This is a key difference from the "substantial input" required by US 2013/0275899 A1.
    Specifically, US10277728, Claim 1, features:

    • "determining without any input by a user that a text message, an email, or a message from a messenger application, has arrived while the user is engaged in an activity;"
    • "informing the user without any input by the user that the text message, the email, or the message from the messenger application has arrived from a sender;"
    • "proceeding with a step selected from the group consisting of (i) and (ii): i) allowing the user time to take an affirmative action to stop reading aloud to the user a body... and in accordance with not receiving an input... reading aloud the body...; ii) allowing the user time to take an affirmative action to command reading a body... and in accordance with receiving an input... reading aloud the body..."
      The emphasis on minimal or no user input for initial notification and the specific "read aloud" mechanisms (opt-out or opt-in with a short delay) differentiates US10277728 from the "substantial input" requirement of US 2013/0275899, thus it may not directly anticipate the "without any input" or the specific hands-free "reading aloud" and interaction model of claim 1.

2. US Patent 8,364,183 B1

  • Full Citation: US 8,364,183 B1, "Cell phone with busykey capability", issued January 29, 2013.

  • Publication Date: January 29, 2013 (Issue Date).

  • Filing Date: October 21, 2011.

  • Brief Description: This patent describes a cell phone modified with software that responds to the press of one or more "Busykeys." This functionality includes automatically sending a pre-typed text message to the sender of the latest text message or automatically answering an incoming call and playing a pre-recorded audio message. US10277728 highlights that this patent "do[es] not allow a person to respond to a text or a call other than by sending a pre-typed text message and still require substantial input from the user since the user has to choose and press on a Busykey button."

  • Potential Anticipation (35 U.S.C. § 102):
    US 8,364,183 B1 relates to handling incoming communications in a "busy" context but relies on explicit user input via a "Busykey button" to activate its functions. This directly contrasts with the "determining without any input by a user" and "informing the user without any input by the user" limitations of US10277728, Claim 1 (a) and (b). Furthermore, US 8,364,183 B1 focuses on sending pre-typed messages or playing pre-recorded audio, not dynamically reading aloud the body of a newly received text message or email, nor offering the distinct opt-in/opt-out reading aloud options of US10277728. Therefore, it is unlikely to anticipate Claim 1 of US10277728 directly due to these key differences in user interaction and content delivery.


3. US Patent 8,526,973 B1

  • Full Citation: US 8,526,973 B1, "Cell phone with busykey capability", issued September 3, 2013.

  • Publication Date: September 3, 2013 (Issue Date).

  • Filing Date: January 24, 2012.

  • Brief Description: This patent is a continuation of US 8,364,183 B1 and describes similar "Busykey" functionality for a cell phone, enabling automatic responses to incoming messages or calls by sending pre-typed messages or playing pre-recorded audio messages upon user activation of a "Busykey." US10277728 provides the same criticism for this patent, stating it "do[es] not allow a person to respond to a text or a call other than by sending a pre-typed text message and still require substantial input from the user since the user has to choose and press on a Busykey button."

  • Potential Anticipation (35 U.S.C. § 102):
    Similar to US 8,364,183 B1, US 8,526,973 B1's reliance on a "Busykey button" for user input and its limited response mechanisms (pre-typed messages, pre-recorded audio) diverge from the core inventive features of US10277728, Claim 1. The "without any user input" clauses and the dynamic "reading aloud the body" of the message (with opt-in/opt-out options) in US10277728 distinguish it from this prior art. Therefore, it is unlikely to anticipate Claim 1 of US10277728.


4. US Patent 8,359,014 B1

  • Full Citation: US 8,359,014 B1, "Cell phone with busykey capability", issued January 22, 2013.

  • Publication Date: January 22, 2013 (Issue Date).

  • Filing Date: April 27, 2012.

  • Brief Description: This patent is also part of the "Busykey" family, sharing the core concept of a cell phone with software that uses one or more "Busykeys" to automatically send pre-typed text messages or play pre-recorded audio messages in response to incoming communications. US10277728 criticizes this patent for the same reasons as its siblings, noting it "do[es] not allow a person to respond to a text or a call other than by sending a pre-typed text message and still require substantial input from the user since the user has to choose and press on a Busykey button."

  • Potential Anticipation (35 U.S.C. § 102):
    Consistent with the analysis of US 8,364,183 B1 and US 8,526,973 B1, US 8,359,014 B1 does not appear to anticipate the critical "without any user input" determination and informing steps, nor the specific "reading aloud the body" and subsequent interaction model defined in US10277728, Claim 1. The fundamental difference lies in the initiation of the response (automatic vs. user-activated "Busykey") and the nature of the information delivered (dynamic message body vs. pre-recorded/pre-typed). Therefore, it is unlikely to anticipate Claim 1 of US10277728.


The analysis shows that US10277728 explicitly differentiates its invention from the cited prior art based on the degree and nature of user input required, particularly in the initial notification and the method of message delivery (reading the body aloud dynamically vs. pre-defined responses). The "without any input by a user" clauses in US10277728, Claim 1, appear to be a key distinguishing feature from the identified prior art.

Generated 5/23/2026, 12:49:24 AM